Book Review: The Age of Shiva
Author: Manil Suri
Pages: 454
Publisher: Bloombury
Price: 399
Published in: 2008
First things first. I think Manil Suri has a tremendous flair for creating drama and an astonishing ability of penetrating into human psyche. Which means, at certain points, The Age of Shiva touches the brilliance of V S Naipaul’s A Home For Mr Biswas in portraying human despair and chaotic family life with all its colourful and despicable characters. The author’s biggest strength lies in creating interesting set pieces and keeping the narrative moving at a frenzied, rapid-fire pace. The language is simple yet wonderfully descriptive. All of this makes the book quite a compelling read.
And yet, the sum total does not add up to make this as ambitious a book as it would like to be.
For one, Manil Suri’s attempt to give the book an epic scale even while keeping it intimate is not always convincing. Spanning a period of 40 years since India’s independence, the story somewhat awkwardly weaves in everything from episodes from the partition, the socio-political events around Nehru’s time, the Emergency…all of it is there. Now, not all these events have a direct bearing on the characters which is what makes it nothing more than a contrivance. Then there is the evocation of myth, traditional rituals like karwa chaut explained in great detail. All of this makes the story a ‘spiced up’ Indian fare but authentically served nevertheless.
As I mentioned, Manil Suri has an acumen for dramatic plot points, which should make him a great script writer. The story’s main thrust is on the mother-son relationship, so the author makes the unusual but intriguing choice of having the nondescript Meera as a narrator, addressing the story to her son, Ashwin. There are strong undercurrents of oedipal love as the reader will discover in the first page itself.
“Do you know how you thrust your feet towards me, how you reach out your arms, how the sides of your chest strain against my palms? Are you aware of your fingers brushing against my breasts, their lips trying to curl around something to hold on to, but slipping instead against my smooth flesh?”
It’s a shock beginning and it would be easy to think of such writing as being titillating. No doubt, the author is a bit of a flame thrower – but the emotional audacity in Manil Suri’s work is undeniable. Meera, as she recounts her story, is the less fortunate daughter of the influential Sawhneys. Her elder sister, Roopa – blessed with superior looks – is pampered at home and she loses no opportunity in taking the nastiest jibes at her younger sibling. By a quirk of fate, however, Meera ends up marrying the guy who Roopa was going around with. Meera feels no particular love for Dev – though his quiet charm is attractive to her- and her decision to marry him is almost entirely driven by the fact that she managed to whisk at least one thing out of her selfish sister.
Meera, after being used to a lavish lifestyle, suddenly finds herself in very modest surroundings. Dev has a joint family, comprising a sympathetic mother-in-law, a vicious sister-in-law (Hema), Dev’ brother Arya and his wife, Sandhya. (Surprisingly, Dev, who one supposes to be a very charming, articulate man going by the affection the two women shower on him, is relegated to the sidelines by the author). It’s a bitter sweet life that Meera leads here, feeling frustrated at one point and at another time warming up to the affection she receives.
The rest can be read at my blog: http://sandyi.blogspot.com/2009/06/age-of-shiva.html
June 30, 2009 at 10:19 AM
Thanks for this great piece Sandy. You rightly suggest that the book has certain flaws of characterization. But I nonetheless found it very affecting.
June 30, 2009 at 10:21 AM
It could be argued that his earlier Death of Vishnu was the more ‘daring’ book in some ways. Many critics in the US certainly preferred the former. But I somehow have a weakness for the latter.
June 30, 2009 at 7:56 PM
Thanks for this review Sandy — although I did enjoy reading this book, like you I felt it was somehow less than the sum of his parts. My favorite portion was this one:
“The book poignantly and sensitively portrays the lives of men and women – crushed and confused by their lot in life. The most heartbreaking episode is of course that of Meera’s intense love for son, her conflicting emotions when she has to unwillingly separate their beds, her utter despair to see him move on with his life. …”
Well said — Suri certainly succeeds in conveying not just the tenderness, but the hungry intensity, the grasping nature of one’s love for one’s child…
June 30, 2009 at 9:21 PM
Thanks Q and Satyam. In spite of my reservations with the book on certain counts, I must say I really enjoyed reading it. And what a fast read this is!
September 24, 2009 at 12:49 PM
Sandy: two books I am awaiting.. I suspect you will like these too:
Wolf Hall: A Novel (Man Booker Prize)
The Children's Book