Having seen the Tamil Raavanan thrice and the Hindi Raavan twice, I strongly felt that I must put my thoughts to writing on these twin efforts by Mani Ratnam. So, despite the fact that in the pieces by Goodfella, Satyam and Qalandar, the movies have already been explored, understood and dissected in great detail; I offer my views on this unfairly dismissed Herculean endeavour by possibly India’s finest contemporary filmmaker. A special shout-out and thanks to Sandy for compelling me to write this piece.
I had already reviewed the Tamil Raavanan for Sakaal Times. I reproduce the review below, followed by my comparative piece on the films.

Almost a perfect 10
Raavanan
Dir- Mani Ratnam
Cast- Vikram Kennedy, Aishwarya Rai, Prithviraj Sukumaran, Karthik Muthuraman, Priyamani Iyer, John Vijay and Prabhu Ganesan
Rating- ****
Krishna has always triumphed over Rama in our films. The staid, if steadfast, ideal God appears too dull for the times we live in. The multifaceted Krishna thus, serves fittingly as a modern God. And by extension, Mahabharata, the text he features in, seems more privileged to address our collective positives and failings. Perhaps why, the Ramayana, of which this Mani Ratnam flick (and its Hindi twin) is an adaptation, can be afforded to be told today not by extolling the deadpan virtues of its colourless God, but in humanizing the hastily vilified antagonist of that piece- the ten-headed demon Ravana.
Read more »










