A list of favorite directors..

Alex inspired me to create a different sort of list of favorite directors (for which his Cocktail passion can almost be forgiven!). I’ve created all sorts of lists in the past of favorite films but over time these never seem very ‘true’. One keeps changing one’s mind. Different films matter more at different points. So it occurred to me that a wiser way of framing things would be to draw up a list of directors from whom one could perhaps watch anything or at least enjoy even relatively mediocre stuff. This very personal list is in no particular order. These are directors I adore more than any others but also those that I find to be ‘for all seasons’ (odd as this might seem for at least one name here!). I don’t think I’ve forgotten anyone here but if I am reminded of an oversight I will extend the list.

1)Mani Ratnam
2)Raj Kapoor
3)Hrishikesh Mukherjee
4)Satyajit Ray
5)Kurosawa
6)Fellini
7)Antonioni
8)Jean-Pierre Melville
9)Sergio Leone
10)John Ford
11)Alfred Hitchcock


And now I shall pick just one favorite film for each of these directors (this was harder to manage in some cases!):

1)Iruvar
2)Bobby
3)Mili
4)Days and Nights in the Forest
5)Kagemusha
6)Nights of Cabiria
7)The Passenger
8)Army of Shadows
9)The Good the Bad and the Ugly
10)Stagecoach
11)North by Northwest

326 Responses to “A list of favorite directors..”

  1. Alex adams Says:

    Nice-much better Satyam
    That earlier top 100 list of yours did ‘disappoint’ me somewhat and this one sort of makes up for it..
    Btw have a knack for ‘squeezing’ out the best from some capable folks
    Recently, motivated utkal uncle regarding cock tail –the results are there to see-‘poetry in motion’
    And this crisper list is very good
    Ps– would invite all other esteemed members here to cum up with their own lists here — would luv to learn from all of u folks
    Thanx

    Like

  2. awwww man!!!! You missed some gr8 directors…I know it’s tough to think up of the best ones, but, I mean Christopher Nolan, Quentin Tarantino, Martin Scorcesse :/

    Like

    • Alex adams Says:

      What’s your list arsh?
      Would invite the lists of utkal uncle, anjali, Amy, Oldgold, Di & others to complete the ‘spectrum’
      Ps: Amy : films of Imran khan, Kareena are banned from any list 🙂

      Like

      • LOL I replied to Satyam’s post very quickly, but, it’s actually really hard to make a list of top 10 directors. For me, off the top of my head, it’s:
        1) Quentin Tarantino
        2) Satyajit Ray
        3) Christopher Nolan
        4) Martin Scorcesse
        5) Hrishikesh Mukherjee
        6) Guru Dutt
        7) James Cameron (partially b/c he’s really creating some gr8 opportunities for the movies to expand visually)
        8) Ang Lee / Anurag Kashyap
        9) Akira Kurosawa
        10) Raj Kapoor/Yash Chopra (they’ve both made some wonderful films…but, i do think that Raj Kapoor’s just a bit better)

        that’s just off the top of my head though…

        Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          Gud list-knew u were more than an Srk Die hard, Arsh ..

          Like

        • I like good movies. Plain ‘n simple. FOR SOME REASON, I didn’t enjoy 3 idiots and Ghajini too much. Actually, I only found 3 Idiots to be a little far fetched. Comedic parts were actually really good, namely Chatur’s speech. Ghajini, I dunno, it wasn’t handled well by Murugadoss.

          AND … i’m a fan of SRK, Aamir and Salman…but, for different reasons. Aamir, purely as a professional actor. SRK, as an actor…but, moreover as an entertainer and a person. Salman Khan…uh, i really don’t know. He just seems like a good man! 🙂

          Why do I put SRK at the of my list??? That’s a personal reason. It’s got something to do with ending life! :/ but, either way…that should give you an idea! 🙂

          Like

    • They wouldn’t make my list of absolute favorites..

      Like

      • Alex adams Says:

        ^ agree Satyam
        These three were(tarantino, scorcese, Nolan) were top of my list in maybe couple of years ago-not sure now..
        as for mallick, Allen they would walk in any list..
        As for Spielberg -he is ‘mr cinema’ -no questions asked
        Ps-am tempted to add guru dutt, bimal Roy ..

        Like

        • have you seen Duel from Spielberg??? What a movie! I ought to thank my brother for telling me about this movie. Amazing! Best.. “on road” movie I’ve ever seen!

          Like

        • Duel is scary …

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          Thanx Arsh
          Ya has been lying in my huge ‘ to see pile’ but couldn’t .. May check it
          Hav a weakness for ‘road flicks’ & ‘on road’ ones..
          Reminds me randomly- there was an abhay deol road movie –sounded interesting-anyone seen it ?

          Like

        • @munna … Duel is awesome though. Last time I went on a road trip with my family, I was scared to overtake a truck :O

          @Alex it’s on youtube. here’s the link, if you wanna check it out!

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          Thanx ash-couldn’t find my ‘duel’copy
          But don’t wanna get scared-due to take some long road trips &@odd times-so will try it after those lol
          Ps- I can’t drive without overtaking/stategic speeding/bullying haha

          Like

        • LOL Alex…yeah that would be a good idea!!! 😀

          Like

  3. Alex adams Says:

    Bobby @ no 2 is still irking me
    With Satyam : ones standards are much much higher
    Won’t rate it at raj kapoors best-my opinion
    And nor would put mili as hrishikeshs best …

    Ps- but these 2 are significantly less wierd & quirky choices than mine 🙂

    Like

  4. Alex adams Says:

    And btw just noted-where is
    Terence mallick
    Steven Spielberg
    Steven soderberg
    Woody Allen
    Even Cameron …
    Ha-I’m a difficult one to please 🙂

    Like

  5. A list consistent with your writings, Satyam. Good stuff.

    Like

  6. My interest in movies is recent and fledgling, I may have seen 2% of the films Satyam has seen but here is the list of my 10 Favorite Hindi films:

    Mughal E Aazam (Grandest)
    Pyaasa (Deepest)
    Heer Ranjha (Magical)

    Do Beegha Zameen
    Do Aankhein Barah Haanth
    Garam Hawa
    Anand
    Saudagar
    Paakejah
    Shakti
    Ardh satya
    Aakrosh
    Salaam Bombay
    Lagaan
    Dev D
    Choti Si Baat
    Ek Duje Ke Liye
    Mera Naam Joker
    Moonson Wedding
    Katha
    Teesri Kasam
    In Custody
    Mother India
    Bandit queen
    Arth
    Satya

    My favorite 3 are on top from then on the List is random and in no particular order.

    Sholay
    Mr India
    Munnabhai MBBS

    These are the most entertaining but mindless.

    Because I haven’t mentioned any film by Ratnam an honorary membership is given to:
    Dil Se

    Like

    • Another great hindi film i had almost forgotten but needs a mention here is Sadma.
      The last scene….. where a soggy kamal hasan is chasing the moving train and trying to make sridevi remember all the childish games they two played together(by making weird faces and poses)…. on the platform….. and the oblivious sridevi takes him for a madcap beggar…. the whole gist of the movie flashed b4 me: The film is a deep meditation on the trauma(sadma) called love.

      Like

      • Another hindi film I am forced to add in my all time great list is Shanghai.the film is definitely the most ambitious film to have come after Ardh satya in bollywood…..and take my word…this film is going to become a cult film.A path breaking film just like ardh satya did.
        Shanghai is a very very disturbing film in the way it questions and makes fun of the self righteous anger of the middle class against corruption. dibakar turns our hatred for corruption on its head….makes it self referential …..just as ardh satya turned the classic fight between right and wrong on its head.
        shanghai is a masterpiece.anurag kashyap was totally justified in raving about shanghai the way he did…the film is a cult classic.

        Like

  7. Interesting list Satyam- I’m very surprised however that you have 2 directors of westerns on there but no masala filmmakers!

    And I had no idea that you like Melville so much- he’s very underrated IMO.

    Like

    • I am a bit conflicted about Desai for a couple of reasons but I might well add him to the list.. part of the thing here is that while I enjoy most of his films very little of the stuff he did without Bachchan is on par. Even with Bachchan I consider all of the work after Naseeb sub-par in some form or fashion.

      Like

      • Agreed with ur views on Desai being inconsistent (even Coolie had issues). But a very interesting list and like always, u have avoided naming the most iconic films of these directors as ur fav. on Milli GF somewhere said that ‘Milli had one of Bachchan’s finest portryals of angry young man)’- My fav Mukherjee film would be Jurmana. And North By Northwest has to be Hitchcock’s most ‘stylish’ and ‘cool’ film if not his best- my fav will be Vertigo here. And i am happy that Ford figures in ur list

        Like

  8. @ satyam
    no scorcese,de sica,bergman????…..
    bobby the best film of raj kapoor??????…hmmm….utkal will b happy.my choice is mera naam joker,jaagte raho(as producer) and satyam shiv sundaram(deep shit)
    nights of cabiria is fellini at his indulgent worst.the movie has fake magic realism.its these type of films that led to the downfall of fellini.my choice is 8 and half….an example of fellini at his indulgent best….genuine magic realism.
    mani ratnam is over hyped.he is a notch above good…but certainly not great.the political and social perspectives in his films are too naive and juvenile.

    Like

  9. Sad but i have not seen a single Antonioni and Melville film. Have only seen 2 of Ray’s films.

    Like

  10. I don’t know if there is much point to making a list of my personal favourites because my list is totally dependant on my mood and keeps changing- but here is a list of my favourite directors at the moment:

    1.Wong Kar Wai- In the Mood For Love
    2.Hayao Miyazaki- Princess Monoke
    3.Jean Luc Godard- Breathless/ Le Mepris
    4.Luis Bunuel- Exterminating Angel/ Discreet Charm
    5.Asghar Farhadi- A Separation
    6.Billy Wilder- Sunset Boulevard
    7.Nora Ephron- Sleepless in Seattle
    8.Jean-Pierre Melville- Le Samourai
    9.Alfonso Cuaron- Y Tu Mama Tambien
    10. Whit Stilman- The Last Days of Disco

    In India cinema:

    1.Shyam Benegal- Bhumika
    2.Hrishikesh Mukherjee- Golmaal
    3.Mira Nair- Salaam Bombay
    4.Guru Dutt- Pyaasa
    5.Mani Ratnam- Mouna Ragam/ Raavanan

    BTW- just to clarify-this is not a list based on Satyam’s criteria where I can enjoy even the most mediocre films of these directors- unfortunately I’m not anywhere near as well-informed about cinema as Satyam- and I haven’t seen the complete filmography of many of these filmmakers.

    Like

    • this is a great list Ami.. interesting to see Whit Stillman on the list!

      Like

      • Satyam- what’s your opinion of Whit Stillman? I think that he’s the most endearing chronicler of privileged America-less ‘precious’ than Wes Anderson, less cynical than Woody Allen and less self-indulgent than Sofia Coppola.

        His genteel/ innocent/witty brand of humour is very Wodehouse- a lovely respite from the non-stop sarcasm/ sexual innuendo of today’s comedy IMO.

        BTW- Have you seen Damsels in Distress?

        Like

        • I can’t believe I forgot to mention Almovodar! I’m going to make an addition to my list:

          3. Pedro Almovodar- Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown.

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          ^^”Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown”-an apt title 🙂
          Sorry : that was a full toss I couldn’t resist –smack-hit for a boundary …

          Like

    • @Ami, Okay so I finally watched Breathless. Goddard has been praised to the skies and the film is a so called revolutionary in its techniques employing handhelds, jump cuts etc which were unheard of in those times. I also get the stylistic treatment employed here and the brisk story telling. And directors don’t really have to be intelligent to make good movies but Goddard is universally acknowledged. But inspite of all this was I entertained for the whole 90 minutes? I would be dishonest if I said yes. I wanted your thoughts on why are you enamoured by Laszlo Kovacs and beyond the universal acclaim were you entertained and if yes why?

      Like

  11. Rohit Shetty, Karan Johar, Sajid Khan? I am pretty sure you have written more about these three than all above named in last 5 years 😉

    Like

    • Alex adams Says:

      ^Haha well said munna
      Actually satyam won’t ever admit but the above three gentlemen have deeply affected satyams psyche -as a counter reqction, satyam writes long posts to try and negate (to himself mostly ) this ‘affinity’
      But like all affinities , they don’t go away
      Terms like ‘masala’, ‘campy’ are then used by satyam to somehow explain (to himself) these idiosyncratic urges 🙂

      Like

  12. Satyam,
    What are your views on Mann, Ridley Scott and Fincher. They probably wouldn’t fit in any all time list but maybe get a mention in terms of some of the best contemporary directors, less so Mann though you have written a lot about Public Enemies. And Ridley did give us Blade Runner as well as the best of the Alien series.

    Like

  13. Favourite films & favourite directors list are extremely subjective, frankly…everyone can have their own lists & argue for the same…needless debates most of the time !!!

    Anyways, my all time favourite 10 directors in no particular order :

    Martin Scorcese
    Steven Spielberg
    Satyajit Ray
    Hrishikesh Mukherjee
    Bimal Roy
    Mani Ratnam
    Quentin Tarantino
    Shyam Benegal
    Govind Nihalani
    Chris Nolan

    Like

  14. Alex adams Says:

    V good lists satyam, anjali and Amy
    Amy-am pleasantly surprised by some names there (which of these have u actually seen –haha just pulling your leg)
    Anjali: lol @ “The film is a deep meditation on the trauma(sadma) called love.”
    Oldgold is not cuming with a list since her list = all films of Srk
    And LS list = all aamir films
    Di list = all vidya balan / arshad warsi (!!) films lol

    Cmon films-keep your list coming: will form a good reservoir list of good films

    Btw plz also add who u think is the best film maker/actor /actress’s alive (Bollywood &holly)!!

    Like

  15. tonymontana Says:

    you guys make me feel so jealous. before joining the blog, I considered myself to be the greatest movie fanatic ever. how sadly mistaken I was..

    Great personal taste Satyam. I dont really share the same thoughts as you when it comes to picking favourites but your list and others’ comments here have reminded me on the number of films I have yet to catch on:

    Nice to see you mention Hrishikesh Mukherjee up there. His narative sense , in my opinion, is still unmatched when it comes to contemporary directors at least..

    Great to see someone mention Woody Allen too.. one might find his comedies too sophisticated in beginning (Annie Hall comes to mind) but Hannah and Her sisters was a delightful. Deep and moving and even heartwarming in places..

    Okies… Got to watch some Meena Kumari films today, I suppose. Its her birthday!

    Like

  16. Alex adams Says:

    May meena kumaris soul rip
    And she gets all the other ‘needs’ (&booze) fulfilled
    Disclaimer:just a joke-don’t want any resident meena kumari fans to suddenly wake up to get offended
    She actually had good taste (in toyboys like Dharmendra )
    Haven’t seen any of her films-any good ones to recommend …

    Like

    • tonymontana Says:

      start with mere apne, Sahib Biwi aur Ghulam or Pakeezah : her best films

      Like

      • Agreed.Apart from those 2 films add Main Chup Rahoongi (unmissable film), Azaad and Dil Apna Aur Preet Parayi to the mix. Otherwise not a Meena Kumari fan. Mere Apne and Angoor are my absolute fav Gulzaar films. Though i liked Parichay, Kinara, Achanak and Hu Tu Tu a lot too.

        Like

        • mere apne and parichay are gulzar at his best.

          Like

        • I’d pick Mausam as his absolute best. mere Apne is very good too. Don’t much care for Parichay.

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          Love gulzars collaborations with rd burman
          This was where rdb really came into his own creatively though this wasn’t his most ‘successful’ phase ala with Rajesh khanna..
          There are loads of popular hit songs
          A little known song that I happened to hear-luv the singing, music and most importantly, the lyrics
          ‘Raah pe rehte hain’
          Enjoy

          Like

        • @Satyam
          Agree on Mausam

          Like

      • Agree on SBG, but “Pakeezah” and “Mere Apne” as Meena Kumari’s best?! She’s like a zombie in the first and a non-presence in the second. I suggest Miss Mary for a happier turn and “Chitralekha” or “Chirag Kahan Roshni Kahan” for more dramatic performances.

        Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          “She’s like a zombie in the first and a non-presence in the second”
          Haha Shalini : with nocturnal activities like that, being a
          Zombie at day is but natural..
          Btw what is your list of favorites ..

          Like

  17. Alex adams Says:

    Thanx tony:do u hav any list
    hav watched bots of sbAg -v good songs
    May watch sbAg (new though)

    Ps: curious to see utkal uncles list (once he is fully done with cocktail ).

    Ps2: “The film is a deep meditation on the trauma(sadma) called love.”
    Hmm may watch this film ..
    Seems anjali is talking by experience 🙂

    Like

  18. http://ktmflower.blogspot.ca/2007/05/importance-of-songs-and-dances-in.html
    didn’t know where to post this. this is a gr8 analysis of the importance of music in bollywood industry. i like it

    Like

  19. Dr shaurya Says:

    Like

  20. I think my tone is often hyperbolic as if I am speaking from a high horse…. acknowledging that…. very humbly and modestly I would like to claim that in any list of the 100 greatest directors of all time Ingmar Bergman’s place will be from 1 to 99.1… and the rest of the 99 filmmakers will be subsumed in the remaining .99

    And again very self deprecatingly and with deepest humility I would declaim that:
    Doubt thou the stars are fire;
    Doubt that the sun doth move;
    Doubt truth to be a liar;
    But never doubt that Bergman did favor to the word “Great” by condescending to be associated with it.

    Like

  21. Utkal Mohanty Says:

    To be frank , it is extremely difficult to list 10 favourite films or directors today – more like favourite 100 films and favourite 30 directors would make any kind of sense. Bit if the game is of 10 overs , so be it. But let me at least have two innings if 10 overs – one for Indian and one for rest of the world. Because that is how I consume films. My mindset, my attitude while watching Indian films is totally different when I am watching films from outside india. Also the lists don’t make any sense without a one-line summing up of ‘ Why?’. So let me try. Though I am listing one film against each director, I am also listing separate list of 10 favourite films. Only those directors feature, of whom I have at least three favorite films. ( All lists are in no particular order)

    Directors: International:

    1. Woody Allen : Annie Hall
    2. Alfred Hitchcock: Psycho
    3. Eric Rohmer: My Night at Mauds
    4. Martin Scorsese: King of Comedy
    5. Isazuro Ozu: Tokyo Story
    6. Ingmar Bergman: Fanny and Alexander
    7. Pedro Almodovar: All About My Mother
    8. Alesandro Inarritu: Amores Perros
    9. Richard Linklater: Before Sunset
    10. David Lean: Brief Encounter

    Directors: Indian:

    1. Satyajit Ray : Pather Panchali
    2. Ritwik Ghatak: Meghe Dhaka Tara
    3. Adoor Goplakrishnan: Mathulikal
    4. Guru Dutt: Pyasa
    5. Anurag Kashyap: Gangs of Wasseypur
    6. Mani Ratnam: Iruvar
    7. Hrishikesh Mukherjee: Anand
    8. Rituparno Ghosh: Utsab
    9. Shekhar Kapoor: Bandit Queen
    10. Bimal Roy: Devdas

    Films: International

    1. Tokyo Story: Ozu
    2. Psycho: Hitchcock
    3. Godfather: Coppola
    4. Aguirre, The Wrath of God: Herzog
    5. Metropolis: Lang
    6. Fanny and Alexander : Bergman
    7. Taxi Driver: Scorsese
    8. Modern Times: Chaplin
    9. Annie Hall: Allen
    10. Tarantino: Pulp Fiction

    Films: Indian

    1. Pather Panchali: Ray
    2. Meghe Dhaka Tara: Ghatak
    3. Mathulikal: Goplakrishnan
    4. Mughal-e-Azam: Asif
    5. Pyasa: Gurudutt
    6. Anand : Hrishikesh Mukherjee
    7. Hum Aapke Hain Koun..? : Barajatya
    8. Amar Akbar Anthony: Desai
    9. Lagaan: Gowarikar
    10. 3 Idiots: Hirani

    Like

  22. Alex adams Says:

    Well, ever simce inviting this list from
    Everyone, I was eagerly expecting yours, utkal uncle ..
    Hopefully u have taken a break (short) from cocktailian activities ..
    A v nice list indeed–cheers

    @anjali-thou art a big Bergman fan -good
    Ps–bu what have u done with poor oldgold
    After your boxing match, she has ran away–c’mon OG -be brave 🙂

    Like

  23. Alex adams Says:

    The paradigm of default ‘devotion’
    My Innocent observation in these ‘lists’
    Pardon my naughty observation, but do see a liberal sprinkling of some ‘cult biggies’ –the ones u can never question, types..
    Usually these are so-called ‘timeless’ etc
    And hence stand the ‘test of time’
    I’m sure it’s not names-dropping, but a genuine peerless quality in these choices
    Ps-would be interesting if someone like satyam or utkal or even anjali, can come up with some such ‘biggies’ that they worshipped earlier but have now lost their flavour …(& why)

    Like

  24. Alex adams Says:

    “To be frank , it is extremely difficult to list 10 favourite films or directors today – more like favourite 100 films and favourite 30 directors would make any kind of sense. ”
    Don’t worry utkal uncle
    The ‘stage is set’ -im being the deejay for the background music ,
    The beautiful ‘dancers’ are ready
    All u need to do is ‘perform’
    Bring on the top 100 list (& same to satyam)
    Ps-I suspect, satyam will have a more ‘comprehensive’ one this time compared to that previous one (with burning train above deewar, and kranti abov trishul!) haha

    Like

  25. Alex adams Says:

    Haha
    When u are dealing with people (like me) with attention span of a kid, u have to repeat (u did mention about personal taste though-not sure of rank lol)
    Anyhow-
    Have a feeling that the new top 100 lists by satyam & utkal (& any other who likes to take these stalwarts on) will he damn special
    Cheers

    Like

  26. Utkal Mohanty Says:

    My god how cold I have missed my most favourite Indian film of all. So out goes 3 Idiots ( we will check how well it ages in 5 years’ time) , in comes , in comes DEEWAR!

    Films: Indian

    1. Pather Panchali: Ray
    2. Meghe Dhaka Tara: Ghatak
    3. Mathulikal: Goplakrishnan
    4. Mughal-e-Azam: Asif
    5. Pyasa: Gurudutt
    6. Anand : Hrishikesh Mukherjee
    7. Hum Aapke Hain Koun..? : Barajatya
    8. Amar Akbar Anthony: Desai
    9. Lagaan: Gowarikar
    10. Dewar: Salim-Javed / Yash Chpra

    Like

    • though i may antagonize a few but i have always thought that shakti was a better and more personal film than deevar…..it is less indulgent and more comprehensive in addressing the theme(both the films have more or less similar themes)
      though deewar remains the cult classic full of iconic moments and dailogues…….but the interactions between dilip and amitabh in shakti were nothing less.and as far as the angry young man persona of amitabh is concerned…..shakti is his best and the most personal film as an actor.i was surprized that it was not featured in any list…on this thread.

      Like

      • Alex adams Says:

        Actually, anjali I agree with u-loved shakti
        Have argued about this Satyam before
        The generational confrontation here between amitabh n Dilip s between two eras/sensibilities..
        Personally always relish these ‘clashes’
        Btw who won the ‘clash’. Is also a debate- who do u think folks
        Ps- Satyam: not sure where those debates/ links are lol

        Like

        • @alex

          You can never win the debate as you are floating soup piece 🙂 LOL

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          Haha bliss: mostly participate in debates not to ‘win’
          U don’t even know that?
          Enjoy the voyeurism and sometimes one enjoys/likes to ‘lose’
          ‘floating’ has some ‘perks’ 😉

          Like

        • brilliant write up.
          ” What is monstrous about the kidnapping sequence at the outset that in turn breeds a great deal of resistance in the son is the very fact that for the father there is never a sense of conflict at this moment. Though he offers lip-service to his parental bond he never experiences any measure of genuine crisis before he decides not to comply with the demand.”
          nice observation.
          though i differ from the conclusion that the questions raised in deewar is not fully answered in shakti……and even if i do accept that thematically deevar scores over shakti(after reading ur brilliant write up!)…. shakti is still aesthetically a better film…..
          the reason why i loved shakti is that it is more personal….the scene in which amitabh is drunk and launches on a helpless soliloquy of anger and frustration….against all forms of fatherism and authority before the hapless smitha patil …..is almost existential in its scope.

          Btw alex in that thread says that he suspects that the write up was done by you. i m sorry but the writing style looks different than yours…..there is a confusion in my mind too:-)

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          Anjali: this writeup is just a ‘trailer’ of the ‘legend of satyam’
          We all kids are ‘learners’ of satyam
          (except in romcom/passion genre where satyam is yet to cum of age 🙂

          Like

        • @ alex
          i agree.Amitabh bachchan and his films is the home turf for satyam (run the peril of debating with satyam on this…at ur own risk)
          for romcom passion genre…we have our passionate utkal uncle.
          but seriously…no one can make me accept that hum aapke hain kaun should feature in any all time fav movies.

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          Anjali : hum aa

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          Didnt really love hum aapke hain kaun it can see where Utkal uncle is coming from
          Its a cult film which started a trend which continued for more han a decade ( even ddlj came after this)
          One shouldn’t look for script or what is happening
          A ‘family feel good’ film – had a certain simplicity …
          Ps: think utkal uncle tripped over Madhuri there 😉

          Like

      • Shakti has never been my fav Bachchan film, I remember shakti for song ‘ Aaj Rapat jaaye’ and one diaogue of Big B, ‘ tum Kaun ho, Main joo bi hoon iss waqt tere malik ka malik hoon’

        Deewar is almost perfect if not perfect.

        Like

  27. Arturo Belano Says:

    Because I love making (and reading) lists, and I was a bit bored, here’s my favorite directors and favorite film of theirs:

    Phillipe Garrel: L’enfant Secret
    Raul Ruiz: Three Lives and Only One Death
    John Cassavetes: Opening Night
    Arnaud Desplechin: My Sex Life…or how I got into an argument/Esther Kahn
    Rainer Werner Fassbinder: Berlin Alexanderplatz/Fear Eats The Soul
    Jean-luc Godard: In Praise of Love/Helas Pour Moi
    Howard Hawks: His Girl Friday
    Jacques Doillon: Family Life
    Leo McCarey: Duck Soup
    Abel Ferrara: Dangerous Game
    Charlie Kaufman: Synecdoche, New York
    Charles Burnett: Killer of Sheep

    Like

  28. Alex adams Says:

    Ahaa Arturo belano-that’s some list !! Good
    Who Are your favorite actors and actresses -Hollywood and Bollywood (if I watch the latter)

    Utkal uncle: uve landed yourselves into the ‘top 100’ list with your cumment above.. So top 10 not enuf now..

    Like

    • Arturo Belano Says:

      Alex: Must I restrict myself to Hollywood?! It might sound a bit pretentious but I don’t really care for actors: I’d rather directors use actors as pure models(Bresson) or just go ahead and work with unprofessionals(Kiarostami). But there are a few actors and actresses I enjoy watching: Mathieu Amalric, Tony Leung-kar Fai, Brad Pitt in comic roles, Robert Downey Jr, Ryan Gosling. Huge fan of Jean-Pierre Leaud; love Kieran Culkin: a woefully underutilized actor who has the ability to make his lines sound as though he made the dialog up on the spot; Jason Schwartzmann.

      I think Anna Faris is a great comic actor; like watching Katherine Hepburn, Hideo Takamine, Lauren Bacall, Monica Vitti, Catherine Deneuve.

      Like

      • Completely agree on Anna Faris. Jason Schwartzman though always looks like he just needs to get punched in the face.

        Like

        • Arturo Belano Says:

          Hahahaha. Well, I’m a big fan.

          Also, can’t believe I left our Robert Mitchum. One of the things I wish to do at some point in life is to make it a mission to watch his entire filmography!

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          How did u find her in ‘what’s your number’..watched bits only
          Liked her rude free spirit ..
          Bridesmaids has brought in its own brand of Chick flickish ‘cool’ ones , it seems-with those ‘jokes’

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          @ Amy- what’s your take on Anna faris btw..

          Like

        • Anna Faris is a very likeable comic actress. I prefer Julia Dreyfus and Isla Fischer though- and of course nobody comes close to Tina Fey’s multi-talented comic brilliance.

          Like

        • On second thought- Lena Dunham definitely rivals Tina Fey in terms of being a fantastic comedic writer-actress- but their type of comedy is so different that I think it’s futile to compare them.

          I find the ‘female Louis C.K.’ description of Lena Dunham to be a very apt one- I can’t think of any female comic actresses that have a similar style to Lena.

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          Nice summary Amy
          Btw who has the most ‘identification factor’ for u..

          Like

  29. Alex adams Says:

    Hmm
    Knew from your ‘name’
    Btw have tried reading ‘savage detectives’ but couldn’t go beyond the first few
    pages (lack of patience)
    But a good ‘travelogue’ and wasn’t it an autobiography with the self/writer totally cut off
    “I’d rather directors use actors as pure models(Bresson) or just go ahead and work with unprofessionals(Kiarostami). ”
    -an invigoratingly brilliant comment: Agree (mostly)
    No, u don’t have to restrict yourselves to Bollywood but with that ‘pseudonym’ I didn’t expect much from Bollywood from u
    But plz include bollywood
    Ps: did u see a recent Bollywood ‘masterpiece’ called ‘cocktail’-just asking randomly

    Like

    • Arturo Belano Says:

      Well, there are some traces of Bolano’s life in that novel, but an autobiography it certainly is not.

      No I haven’t seen Cocktail. Don’t intend to either.

      Hindi film actors? Hmm. I find Ranvir Shorey quite entertaining. Other names would be the obvious ones: Amitabh Bachchan, Naseeruddin Shah, Smita Patil, Madhabi Mukherjee, Utpal Dutt.

      Like

      • Alex adams Says:

        Wow:^^This will be the biggest day in the life
        Of ranbir shorey 🙂
        Apparently, some whom I trust,loved his act in Mithya that I haven’t seen.(personally not his biggest fan)
        As for ek tha tigger -the only thing that has enthused me till now has been a short xchange bw shorey/salman
        Salman:
        Mission ke liye zoya ko pataana zaroori hai.
        Shorey:
        Pataate Pataate kahin khud naa pat jaana l
        Haha.. Cunning

        Like

  30. Alex adams Says:

    Reminds me of a book I may finish(read bits)
    A quick reckoner-the ‘savage detectives’
    “The savagery of the title is the savagery of youth—poetry, poverty, fiery idealism, quick fucks, blind drive, the threat of violence, and violence itself. The detection is more adult (less poetry, more poverty, fading idealism, slower fucking, slow drift, and violence itself) and no less savage. Both are hard-earned”

    Like

  31. Alex adams Says:

    Before anyone starts reading this book of bolano, footprint go through this interesting piece, someone had sent me and I have retrieved now..
    Which drew me to the book initially

    ‘the geometry of fiction’
    http://quarterlyconversation.com/roberto-bolano-the-geometry-of-his-fictions

    Like

  32. tonymontana Says:

    great job utkal, anjali, ami and Arturo. I am terribly interested in checking out the films u guys have talked about. possibly satyam can create a link and post it permanently on the top right corner of the page, so that mere mortals can keep checking and revisiting the thread if necessary.. if only to check the important films they have missed.

    Trantino is my all-time fav. But I would include Scorsese, Hitchock, Stanley Kubrick, Polanski, and Hrishida when it comes to compiling a list of all-time favourites.. baaki sab ki picturein aadhi adhoori yahaan wahan se dekhi hain.. would be checking some soon.

    Like

  33. In no particular order my 10 personal favorite directors(Bollywood) with my absolute fav movies are :

    * Vijay Anand – Guide, Jewel Theif, Tere Ghar Ke Samne, Johny Mera Naam

    * Raj Kapoor – Shree 420, Barsaat, Awaara, Bobby

    * Hrishikesh Mukharjee – Golmaal, Anand, Bemisaal, Namak Haraam

    * Sai Paranjpe – Chashme Budoor, Katha, Sparsh

    * Manmohan Desai – AAA, Suhaag, Coolie, Naseeb

    * Prakash Mehra – Muqaddar Ka Sikandar, Sharaabi

    * Yash Chopra – Deewar, Trishul

    * Subhash Ghai – Karma, Karz, Ram Lakhan

    * Mukul Anand – Agneepath, Hum

    * Raj Kumar Santoshi – Ghayal, Ghatak, Khakee, Legend Of Bhagat Singh

    * Raj Kumar Hirani – Munna Bhai MBBS, Three Idiots, Lage Raho

    * Ram Gopal Verma – Satya, Rangeela, Kaun, Sarkar Raj

    PS : My criteria was at-least two movies of each director should be my personal favorite.

    Few others with one film wonder(for me) are :

    Suraj Barjatya : Maine Pyaar Kiya

    Aditya Chopra : DDLJ

    Rakesh Om Prakash Mehra : Rang De Basanti

    Like

  34. Alex adams Says:

    Thanx yakuza
    Quite a comprehensive sensible honest (& unpretentious) list cheers

    Like

  35. Chalo mai bhi list banata hoo just for kicks- bwood- Desai (AAA/Parvarish), Mehboob Khan (Mother India, Aan), Prakash Mehra (Zanjeer), Vijay Anand (Johnny Mera Naam), B.R.Chopra (Kanoon), Kamal Amrohi (Mahal), V. Shantaram (Do Aankhe Barah Haath), Raj Kapoor (Awaara, Bobby), Benegal (Junoon, Nishant), Bimal Roy (Do Bigha Zameen), Nihalani (Ardhasatya, Vijeta), Hrishida (Jurmana, Golmaal), Mahesh Bhatt (Saaransh, Kaash, Naam), Santoshi (Khaaki, Ghayal), Bhardwaj (Maqbool), Rathnam (Nayagan, Geethanjali)

    Like

  36. Unlike others here the range and number of movies I’ve watched is quite limited. Given this handicap giving a list of directors will be neither here nor there; instead a list of movies will be much more representative of my taste. Here are some of the movies that I’ve loved over the years in no particular order:

    Citizen Kane
    Sunset Blvd
    Dial M for Murder
    Vertigo
    Rear Window
    Psycho
    12 Angry Men
    Breathless
    The 400 Blows
    Dr.Strangelove
    The Good, The Bad And The Ugly
    The Godfather
    The Godfather II
    Chinatown
    Taxi Driver
    Annie Hall
    Manhattan
    The Shining
    Blade Runner
    Raiders of the Lost Ark
    When Harry Met Sally
    Terminator II
    The Age of Innocence
    Children of Heaven
    LA Confidential
    The Big Lebowski
    Memento
    Catch Me If You Can
    There Will Be Blood
    Shutter Island

    Awaara
    Jewel Thief
    Anand
    Zanjeer
    Piya Ka Ghar
    Chupke Chupke
    Sholay
    Deewar
    Amar Akbar Anthony
    Trishul
    Kaala Patthar
    Chhoti Si Baat
    Golmal
    Angoor
    Lawaaris
    Ardh Satya
    Karz
    Masoom
    Arjun
    Mr.India
    Qayamat Se Qayamat Tak
    Parinda
    Ghayal
    Andaz Apna Apna
    Coolie No.1
    Satya
    Dil Se
    Kaun
    Munnabhai MBBS
    The Blue Umbrella
    Khakee
    Haasil
    Khosla ka Ghosla
    Udaan

    Like

  37. Alex adams Says:

    Think people will agree that this was a v good list matrix-‘balanced’
    Don’t think u watch as few movies as u r claiming to haha

    Like

  38. Alex adams Says:

    Hahah
    I’m enjoyin the voyeuristic delights 😉

    Like

  39. Alex adams Says:

    Top 100 Now
    Let’s see if anyone can cum up with a damning top 100 list!!
    Think utkal uncle has been huddled in his office for sometime
    Can someone compete with him!!
    Cum on folks –daunting yes-not impossible
    Ps-even satyam is quiet for sometime with the list

    Like

  40. Nice coincidence 🙂

    Sightandsound release their Top 10 films and directors in ‘Once a Decade’ poll

    CRITICS TOP 10 FILMS OF ALL TIME

    1. Vertigo (Hitchcock, 1958)

    2. Citizen Kane (Welles, 1941)

    3. Tokyo Story (Ozu, 1953)

    4. La Regle du jeu (Renoir, 1939)

    5. Sunrise: a Song for Two Humans (Murnau, 1927)

    6. 2001: A Space Odyssey (Kubrick, 1968)

    7. The Searchers (Ford, 1956)

    8. Man with a Movie Camera (Dziga Vertov, 1929)

    9. The Passion of Joan of Arc (Dreyer, 1927)

    10. 8 ½ (Fellini, 1963)

    DIRECTOR’S TOP 10 FILMS

    1. Tokyo Story (Ozu, 1953)

    =2 2001: A Space Odyssey (Kubrick, 1968)

    =2 Citizen Kane (Welles, 1941)

    4. 8 ½ (Fellini, 1963)

    5. Taxi Driver (Scorsese, 1980)

    6. Apocalypse Now (Coppola, 1979)

    =7 The Godfather (Coppola, 1972)

    =7 Vertigo (Hitchcock, 1958)

    9. Mirror (Tarkovsky, 1974)

    10. Bicycle Thieves (De Sica, 1948)

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-19078948

    Like

    • these are the usual suspects in the current age. The previous Sight and Sound poll wasn’t dramatically different from this one. Zizek makes the point and I think he’s right that Vertigo is becoming (if it hasn’t already) the central film of the age as surely as Citizen Kane was for so long. And ironically Vertigo didn’t do too well on initial release. It was just about ok.

      Like

  41. tonymontana Says:

    That’s an expected list. these films would probably feature among the top a decade down the line too.. its hard to beat nostalgia whether you talk of Hindi cinema or western cinema in general.

    Like

  42. tonymontana Says:

    Btw has anyone seen the most recent Polanski film named Carnage (Kate Winslet, Jodie Foster, Christopher Watz). I thought it was an interesting conversation based film that had a lot of darkly funny comic moments with good acting by all.
    Those who stay in the US must be aware of the TV series on basis of which Polanski co-wrote its screenplay

    Like

    • Haven’t seen it yet but it’s based on a Play.

      Like

      • tonymontana Says:

        you must satyam.. it was good fun.. cant believe I ended up laughing so hard in a film where the comic moments were this subtle

        Like

        • Polanski actually has a great knack for comic moments. I’d been meaning to see this for some time. Saw the play and didn’t loveit or anything but with that cast and Polanski at the helm it was something I’d wanted to check out.

          Like

        • Yes, saw this and enjoyed it quite a bit. Enjoyed the Q&A with Waltz and John Reilly in special features. Waltz was asked whether “he has finally arrived”? Waltz gave a wonderful answer something to the effect that he didnt really want to “arrive” so soon. He is looking at least at a couple of decades in this field and if he arrives so soon he will have nothing to look forward to. I thought that was a great answer. John Reilly is kind of an odd man out here among the foursome though.

          Like

        • Carnage was too derivative of that vastly superior film- The Exterminating Angel- for me to be able to enjoy it. Not to mention that the whole ‘disintergrating of the civilized facade’ premise worked much better in the surrealist atmosphere of Bunuel’s film.

          Like

    • Liked Carnage…
      Very similar one room “Tape”

      Like

      • Tape I believe might have also been based on a play. Again not the type of thing I’m a big fan of but it had its moments and any Linklater work is worth checking out.

        Like

  43. Hrishi da is on most of the lists but what no one listed Anupama? We have Sharmila Tagore in her best role. Although not ordinarily a good actress she was able to mirror all the subtle emotions the role demanded; she’s perfect here. Then there’s Dharmendra also at his best (and I mean acting though as far as I am concerned Dharam can carry a movie just by his looks); great music –Kuch dil ne kahaa is one of Lata Mangeshkar’s (and my) favorite song; a different take on the usual girl-getting-married story and all these ingredients skillfully put together by Hrishida.

    Like

  44. Alex adams Says:

    “Hrishi da is on most of the lists but what no one listed Anupama”
    Sophy Chaudhuri : u can put up your own list with anupama in it..

    Like

    • Not a bit like sophy chaudhuri whoever the heck he/she/it is. Haven’t seen as many movies as the professional movie watchers here on this blog 😉 so won’t attempt a list. Just trying to correct for bias there.

      Like

  45. Alex adams Says:

    Ok no problem – ‘just’ sophy Marceau ….
    Btw thanx for reminding me that I also hav other ‘work’ to do.. Haha
    Gud nite folks…

    Like

  46. Here is a list of my greatest books of all time and i promise I will stick to only those books I have read:

    Zorba The Greek by Nikos Kazatzakis(Greek writer)

    Don Quixote by Cervantes(Spanish writer)

    Moby Dick by Hermann Melville (American writer)

    Hamlet by Shakespeare (English Writer)

    Thus Spake Zarathustra by Nietzche (German writer)

    Steppenwolf by Hermann Hesse (German writer)

    Trial by Kafka (German writer)

    The Fall by Albert Camus (French Writer)

    Notes From The Underground by Dostoevsky (Russian writer)

    Deewan E Ghalib by Ghalib (Urdu writer)

    Nadiya Ke Dweep by Ageyay (Hindi writer)

    Afsaane(Short stories) by Shahadat Hasan Manto(Urdu writer)

    The Prophet by Khalil Gibran (Arabic writer)

    Madame Bovary by Flaubert (French writer)

    Lost Illusions by Balzac (French writer)

    Lolita by Nabokov (Russian wrote in English)

    Tin Drum by Gunter Grass (German)

    Accidental Death Of An Anarchist by Dario Fo (Italian writer)

    In The Heart Of Darkness by Joseph Conrad(Polish wrote in English)

    Old Man And The Sea by Hemingway (American Writer)

    Hunger by Knut Hamsun (Norwegian writer)

    The Killing Joke by Alan Moore (Comics writer, English)

    Like

    • Love how you’ve put up that list…

      Hamlet by William Shakespeare (English writer) or Hemingway (American writer) and so on!

      reminds of that Hollywood movie — Leo Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina!

      Like

      • Of the books you mention- I love The Fall and Accidental Death Of An Anarchist. I also like Madame Bovary and Don Quixote. Very interesting list Anjali.

        Sadly I haven’t read much Urdu/ Arabic literature. And with Nietzche- I’ve never been able to finish any of his books- I really dislike his style of writing and find it a chore to get through. I don’t care much for Hemingway either- his starkly minimalist style of writing leaves me cold.

        Like

      • LOL, I think Anjali’s manner speaks volumes about what she thinks of her audience.

        Like

        • @ Q
          That’s very unfair of you.
          Do u see the slight difference between fair and unfair?…..just take out the (un) from unfair and the whole meaning changes. For example the word “HELLO”(a form of greeting) becomes …………..”O HELL”(imprecation)….by merely replacing the O from the last to the first. “God is nowhere”….becomes……………………. “God is now here”….by mere change in the spacing of W.
          How to determine human motivation?…it is something so fleeting and a chameleon.
          why did I say: “i promise I will stick to only those books I have read?”
          Was it because there are in fact a few books in the list i haven’t read?and i was insecure and wanted to stress before one and all that i have in fact read them all?
          Or is it to pique you all by this slight affront into reading my post because i did not want it to go unnoticed?
          Or was there a genuine disrespect from my side to you all?
          what was the real version of my motivation?
          How to fix something as breezy,ever changing and a chameleon.. like a human Mood or Motivation into something definite?All the versions are in a toss…..and man is the juggler…uses one or the other as per his/her convenience.

          Like

        • ufff anjaliji, I was honestly joking. Agar aap ko bura laga, to maazirat chahta hoon…

          Like

      • Satyam you have a dry wit.

        Like

    • Re: “i promise I will stick to only those books I have read”

      Are you suggesting the rest of us weren’t?!

      Ha ha, just kidding…couldn’t resist that one.

      Like

    • Ohh! I had forgotten 2 of my favorite writers.
      Thanx to Satyam for reminding me.
      Yes they will also come in Leo Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina format….which Satyam loved so much:

      Gargantua And Pentagruel by Mighty Rabelais (French Writer)
      Bijak (poetry) by Kabir (Hindi Writer)

      Like

  47. Happy Raksha-Bandhan to everyone here and especially the ‘girls’- Anjali, Ami, Oldgold, Bliss, LS and others.I hope all u folks are celebrating it. What abt folks living outside India (Satyam, GF, Alex)?

    Like

  48. @Ami, my list is more contemporary as I have not really visited the classics such as by Fellini et al. Apologize before hand for that. Also it is mainly a Hollywood one.

    Scorcese: Taxi Driver
    David Fincher: Seven, Fight Club
    Michael Mann: Heat
    Ridley Scott: Alien, American Gangster
    Sergio Leone: Good Bad and Ugly, Once Upon a time in America
    Alfred Hitchcock: North by Northwest
    Nolan: Prestige, The Dark Knight Series
    Terrence Mallick: Days of Heaven
    Stone: Wallstreet
    Tarantino: Reservoir Dogs

    Again it’s a very personal list, not necessarily the greatest.

    As for books, I can talk about my favorite companies instead…ie. I can talk my book!

    Like

    • This is a great list Pranav. Pleased to see Coens (though my favs from them are Blood Simple and Raising Arizona) and Mann (Last Of the Mohicans and Heat)

      Like

      • Thanks Saurabh; I like Blood Simple a lot too, but Big Lebowski remains my absolute favorite. There are like more than 50 unique quotes/one liners in the movie. The movie has a cult following similar to Fight Club.

        What are your other interests besides movies and obviously medicine. Though I suspect you probably don’t get much time outside of these. Your comments are generally crisp and lucid.

        Like

        • Thanks Pranav but my comments are frankly far from being crisp and lucid unlike u folks- Now before joining MBBS I did have few hobbies (though can’t say i was good at any)- I played mainly Cricket (only thing i feel i knew a bit abt), Squash, Polevault, Boxing, Field Hockey, Skating (also was interested in quite a few other ones). Quizzing, Reading books, Comic Books, Environmental Sciences and Ecology, HAM Radio, Indian Mythology and History, playing mouth-organ etc

          Like

    • Great list Pranav- Alien is one of my favourite films as well. And you don’t have to apologize for not including European classics at all!

      BTW- it looks like I’m going to have to watch North by Northwest now that it’s been featured on almost everybody’s list of favourites…

      Like

      • Thanks Ami. North ny North West is a good one. But generally I feel that sometimes when you revisit movies that are say more than 30 to 40 years old they appear pretty dated.

        Like

  49. Forgot the smilie at the end, 🙂 hehe

    Like

  50. If I may add an eleventh one:
    Coen Brothers: The Big Lebowski

    Like

    • Pranav, this is one movie I can’t get enough of; can watch it anytime. Too many quotable quotes. Find the self righteous Walter to be a perfect foil for the laid-back dude- a lot of the comedy comes from this contrast.

      Like

  51. Sorry, have to add a 12th one:
    David Mamet: Glengary Glen Ross, Alec Baldwin in the role of a lifetime.

    Like

  52. tonymontana Says:

    Happy Rakshabandhan to all.

    Have a great day exchanging rakhis and gifts if necessary

    Like

  53. Ok lemme be the spoil sport… my favourtie books are

    Non- Fiction

    Roses in December by Hon’ble Mr Justice M C Chagla

    If one is interested to know about the greatest judge in memory of indian Judicial History, one should read about the extraordinary life of this man, his struggles, his achievements and culmination of a great career….. Even though The Judge retired as Chief Justice of Bombay High Court, but his judgements are respected and revered all over India, and treated with great respect and authority on the subject and field, A Legend.

    note: in his entire career he never kept a case judgement pending as was the trend, it is said only twice in 18 years he kept them pending, rest of the occasion they were dictated from dias immediately after arguments were completed.

    My Life (Law and other things) by Ld former Attorney General of India M C Setalvad (satyam can learn brevity from this Man 🙂 )

    The Controversial book, as such the man is most blunt and honest as one gets in his views and one can see that through out the pages of this epic.In Indian Legal History, if there is one man whose has a style of arguments dedicated to himself it is Mr Setalvad’s Brief argument style… it is said he was so brief that sometimes after few sentences he didnt felt necessity to speak..

    Nani Palkhiwala: Court Room Genius : by Soli Sorabjee and Arvind Datar

    Indian Constitutional Law owes itself big time to Mr Palkhiwala, the man who protected the nation against tyranny of laws, the book highlights the origin and meteoric rise… and the landmark cases which are founding pillars of this country, i will ask the reader to read specially the His Holyness Keshvananda bharati ‘s Case Chapter, as it was his finest hr before the Bench, he argued for 31 days non stop, with the result being protection of Constitution’s “Basic Structure” with a slender 6.6 : 6.4 (actually it was 7 : 6, but the judgement which tilted the odds was written and authored by the great Justice H R Khanna whose judgement till the very end was going against the Basic structure before making a brahmaputra style curve turn… to make it 7 : 6) many of this great cases were fought without any cost by the great man.

    Before Memory Fades…. by Fali Nariman

    A simple introduction is he is the man who defended the Union Carbide in Bhopal Gas Tragedy’s case, yes if that makes an impression, than i will tell you India had Jinnah, Palkhiwala and then there was Nariman… no one will ever match his wit and wisdom in court room, a genius beyond parallel, and a very interesting life story… before he forgets…. Before His Memory Fades…

    (Fiction)

    Not a penny more nor less by Jeffrey Archer

    Angels and Demon by Dan Brown

    Rage of Angels by Sydney Seldon

    The Street lawyer by John Grisham

    The seven minutes by Irving Wallace

    Five point Someone by Chetan Bhagat 🙂 (the source behind 3 idiot)

    Like

  54. @ Mks Rooney
    What about “?Ramjethmalani:The Authorized Biography by Nalini Gera?
    Loved the book.

    Like

    • I have yet to read, keeping it pending…. and hoping to find time and motivation…

      Like

    • Interestingthing abt Ram Sir, is that great lawyers came and went… but he was the best criminal lawyer in 1960’s and he is still the best….

      some longevity…

      Like

      • ram sir? r u a lawyer too? in india?
        i have a 5 yr degree in law

        Like

        • Same here, i too have a 5 year degree in law. 🙂

          ps- Qalander bhai, is also a great lawyer.

          Like

        • mksrooney: just a lawyer buddy!

          Like

        • well sir you are a great person!
          had no idea!
          i passed my law in 2011 from NUJS.Kolkata.
          had rather poor grades(was too much lost in existential literature back then) couldn’t get a campus placement.
          top notch law firms like amarchand,jyotisagar,fox mandal,trilegal…had no place for me.
          was offered jobs at Lpos like pangea n stuff did not take it.
          so am preparin for CA now.
          But have great regard for working lawyers.

          Like

        • RE: “was offered jobs at Lpos like pangea n stuff did not take it.”

          Coincidentally, I work for Pangea3! And was at the NUJS campus in August 2011 for some on-campus recruitment…

          Like

        • wow!
          well Q
          nujs students dont really like to work for Lpos(this is not meant in any way as a disrespect to u or pangea)… but u must be knowing this.only the last rankers i guess last 5 or 6 ppl sit for it.pangea conducted a test in 2011.it was online test….. some english and legal contract reading stuff…..

          i was not offered a job by pangea as i never sat for it.some 4 or 5 students may have…but pangea did not take them.
          even if students don’t get campus placement…still they don’t sit for lpos coz they become like a joke before others(this is not meant to disrespect yu)
          so when i said i ws offered…i meant like….lpo job was for the taking but i did not sit for it.
          but am i rite?pangea did not take any? i was not in the recruitment comm so i m not sure

          Like

        • We did actually hire a few people from NUJS — not sure of the numbers, but I believe 2-3.

          Ha ha, no disrespect felt 🙂

          Best of luck as far as the CA is concerned…

          Like

        • but i remember pangea was offering us 60 k.not a bad sum.

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          A small world haha
          Think anjali is v bright
          And should be given advice /guidance etc from the ‘seniors’ in that profession here …Cheers
          Ps- thanx for all the great lists of movies/ books that are trickling in …

          Like

        • @qalander bhai… in my eyes you are great along with GF and satyam, like the holy trinity od article 14,19 and 21 of constitution of india. 🙂

          @anjali…

          no re, i just started my practice a year or two back.. i visited this great forum of satyam since college days (was more frequent then)

          i am what people would say “raw struggling junior” , i am just doing and enjoying work right now 🙂

          great to know about you, i have special regards for Kolkatta, as if you would have read few articles of in that link, one name is Chief Justice Bhaskar Bhattacharya, a great jurist, and a great human being… Lordships are from Calcutta, and its a honor and priviledge to argue in the court of such a highly distinguished man from Calcutta.

          Best wishes for Your CA. I had a chance of joining amarachand, tri legal, AZB, etc as i had the occasion to top the University of Mumbai, but i decided i wasnt cut for corporate job, i am more a cosntitutional lawyers with good range in civil, criminal and company law. So decided to start normal practice in Ahmedabad, Gujarat my birth place.

          But i have had the occasion to read your comments madam, and i have to say you will definitely make it big, … Best wishes for CA

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          Y dont u all start a ‘joint practice’
          Do remember who gave u the idea first haha
          “have had the occasion to read your comments madam, and i have to say you will definitely make it big, … Best wishes”
          Totally agree rooney
          All the best anjali …

          Like

        • @mks rooney
          great to know you sir.
          and its great u r in litigation.i never explored the field of litigation much as i had no practical idea how to go about it.
          after not getting a campus recruitment…i decided to do ca.
          but thx…for ur best wishes.

          Like

        • @ alex
          thnx…i sure have always been in need of guidance.

          ps: well i feel now i have to b more diplomatic here…and cant be my usual loud mouthed on a high horse self 🙂

          Like

  55. Here are some of my favorite books on investments and related stuff. I am just going by memory so might lose out on a few.

    Michael Lewis: The Big Short, The new new thing, Money ball. Michael Lewis needs no introduction.

    Roger Lowenstein: Buffet, When Genius failed. Find Lowenstein just amazing and much better than the overrated Sorkin who wrote Too Big to Fail.

    Robert Hagstorm: The Warren Buffet Way, not the greatest book but refers in very simple language to an investing frame work used by the great one. Used it when I started out in the business.

    Daniel Yergin: The Prize, Yergin is an authority on oil and it’s history and relevance.

    Nassim Taleb: Fooled by Randomness, The Black Swan. A mercurial guy who believes luck plays a big role in investing success. He had the gall to call Buffet “lucky”. Will forgive him for that.

    India unbound: Guruchran Das. I am sure this book is probably not the best one on the Indian renaissance but I like it.

    The intelligent investor by Ben Graham. The bible.

    The greatest Trade: Zeff Zukerman. Only good because it details how John Paulson made $ 6 billion personally in one year shorting the mortgage CDS market.

    Jobs by Walter Issacson. My personal favorite. Shows what a flawed yet mercurial individual Jobs was.

    General rantings of Bill Gross. With more a trillion dollars in bond assets he is the Bond King. Work right across from his building in Newport Beach and walk in to him every now and then.

    Like

    • Thanx.. interesting list, have heard abt few.. but yet never had the motivation to get down reading…. 😦

      Like

      • Thanks Rooney. I hear you; if you don’t have anything to do with the field tough to find motivation to read them.

        Like

        • Ahaha- I should probably read some of these. I’m interning at an investment bank right now and it’s getting increasingly hard to keep up the pretence that I know what I’m talking about! 😛

          Like

        • Alex adams Says:

          “I’m interning at an investment bank right now”Hmm good Amy
          Another bright gal …
          Taking about ‘interns’-ok lemme stop 🙂

          Like

        • Haha sure. The best intro to banking is Liars Poker by Michael Lewis. Investment banking is a great training ground for private equity or buy side which is what I do. Most of my colleagues have a banking background even though I do not. Get a few years under the belt and with that experience and preferably an MBA from a top school some one as bright and classy as you will be set to conquer the world. If you can analyze businesses even half as good as you do movies on here, most firms would hire you in a heart beat.

          Like

        • You are far too kind Pranav 🙂 But I don’t think I’m cut out for a career in investing banking- a few well-respected investment banks/ financial services companies were on campus at my uni conducting interviews for summer placements- I applied for a job on a whim and I was pretty shocked when I was offered an internship- to be perfectly honest I only accepted it because I thought it would look good on my CV. 😛

          But I was just thinking today that I should read a few books on banking if I want to get through this internship- so your reccomendations are most timely. 🙂

          Like

        • Ami and Pranav, both of u seem extremely brigh. The sad thing abt Medical is that the course duration is just too long- i still atleast have 5more years of studies left. And u guys start minting money at a very early age. I am sure Ami must be one of the toppers of her college. And Pranav, this just seems like a herculean pile of books u have listed. You know it always feels great when fellow Indians go abroad and do well (actually Pranav seems to be doing really well).BTW sadly I have no idea abt banking

          Like

  56. so…um, today was a horrible day, movie wise. Sat myself down to watch the worst of the worst…ended up watching RGV’s Aag, Jaani Dushman, and … unfortunately Twilight 😦
    Now, if you’ll excuse I’m gonna go enjoy my newly found respect for life!

    Like

    • Thanks for your kind words Saurabh. Medicine is actually a very noble profession. Based on your and Q’s discussion in a different thread about comics, I ordered the graphic novels of Sin City and Dark Knight returns. I own a copy of Alan Moores watchmen and also the DVD. I have a friend who has analyzed this movie/comic on so many different levels he could write a book on it.

      Like

  57. Alex adams Says:

    Arsh were u being punished ..lol

    Anjali: no need to leave your ‘high horse’ definitely not the ‘horse’..
    That’s the attitude …
    I believe in ‘kingsize’ mentality (internally atleast) 🙂

    Like

  58. Alex adams Says:

    “LOL … yeah, self punishment for sitting at home all day :O”
    Haha Arsh : sadomasochism
    So u did it to yourselves -good man.. Haha
    Btw will see ‘duel’ after a few road trips..thanx

    Like

    • LOL. In a way? I actually enjoyed Aag. Hilarious!!! that one stupid scene with the new “kaalia” and Babban was stretched to almost 15 minutes. Found that hilarious…also, any time Veeru and Heero were talking about something important, the background music completely drowned that. amazinggggg! I actually found a review on it…it’s more of a comedic take. should check it out

      Like

  59. Sheetal Varma Says:

    Wow , those lists are extensive! Never got the chance of watching many movies but my fav from those I got to watch are ( not in any order)
    1 Bimal Roy
    2 Kurosawa
    3 Satyajit Ray
    4 Fellini
    5 Guru Dutt
    6 Mani Ratnam
    7 Wong Kar Wai
    8 Raj Kapoor
    9 Gulzar
    10 Hrishikesh Mukherjee

    Like

  60. Alex adams Says:

    Satyam:
    Good to see this thread of ours becoming a meeting point and ‘breeding ground’ for all varied cineastes and book afficianados around the world 🙂
    Ps:
    Am very happy to note that it is also serving as a ‘career counselling/ guidance’ portal of sorts
    🙂
    Ps- Sheetal : crisp n balanced list there thanx

    Like

  61. Sataym,

    Have you read this, if so want to know your ‘laser beam’ insight 🙂

    A free replay (notes on Vertigo) by Chris Marker

    http://www.chrismarker.org/a-free-replay-notes-on-vertigo/

    Like

  62. Earlier I probably inspired Satyam to come up with his favourite directors list!
    But his comparison of kashyap with rohan sippy(!) though not totally inappropriate made me think
    What are the Indian directors I really respect /admire CURRENTLY
    In my case, it can keep changing
    This is not an ALLTIME list (only current) and does not include Hollywood/french/etc
    But the few I truly respect amongst Indian directors/producers currently
    No genre/no privilege /no budget/no other affiliation-
    As per respect and the ones whose films I will WANT to watch-
    In no particular order amongst INDIAN makers–
    Kamalahassan
    Mani ratnam
    Anurag kashyap
    Shekhar kapoor
    maybe I’m missing someone but that’s it
    xxxxx
    Notable mentions-
    Dibakar banerjee
    Rakesh Mehra
    Imtiaz Ali (yes!)
    Aamir khan (overall film sense)
    Farhan/zoya Akhtar
    xxxxx
    Nearly there but not there-
    Raju hirani (his genre maybe but not lesser really)
    Rgv (due to his recent sins otherwise he deserves to be in the top bunch !)
    Aditya chopra /kjo ( for their production ie manipulations)
    Disclaimer/0: thus doesn’t include past directors & doesn’t include Hollywood/world cinema
    2: sometimes do watch some unmentionable stuff but rhats to do with what gets released on the big screen near me– also sometimes it is good to ‘unwind’ and watch some fun stuff
    But that stuff always never gets into any worhtwhile mention/lists
    Some recent masala/popular/mainstream stuff I liked-
    Dabang
    Ghajini
    Rowdy rathore
    Don 2( yes!)
    Needless to add-rockstar, ZNMD, cocktail 🙂

    Like

  63. Haha
    The disclaimer says -‘current’ filmmakers -so raj kapoor (& many others out)
    The actual ‘core list’ should read as -in no order-
    Kamalahassan
    Mani ratnam
    Anurag kashyap
    Shekhar kapoor
    ONLY

    Like

    • Shekhar Kapur hasn’t made a worthwile film in probably 20 years! before this I do have a weakness for Masoom but overall there has been a certain ‘cult’ of Shekhar Kapur which is grossly disproportionate to anything he’s done!

      Like

  64. The cladh of titans (current)
    I maybe missing some but that’s the core list for me really as far as the Indian current scene is-
    Though in the case of SK (shekhar kapoor) the factor of ‘laurels of the past’ appears to be too much in play
    But as I said-
    Certain types of brilliance blinds me
    Amongst these four, one comes into the ‘elite business cohort’ and THEN one can start discussing further
    And dissecting further…
    Am curious to read your views on this Satyam and from other esteemed members on what they opine on these four and now they would rate em( if they consider them worth rating, obviously )

    Like

  65. So yes: u thought right
    I’m slowly but surely coming to a difficult, tricky, contentious terrain of–
    Who is the greatest Indian film maker alive (ie active)?

    Like

    • That’s pretty easy. It’s Adoor. Next up (and in a more commercial sense) it’s Ratnam. Can’t think of a third filmmaker to join this list either at the Adoor end of the spectrum or the Rathnam one. Kamalahasan just doesn’t have enough films to be fairly compared impressive as his efforts have been.

      If I had to pick the most ‘interesting’ contemporary filmmaker otherwise and based on whatever they’ve done so far I would be tempted to go with Bala.

      Like

  66. And surely one can appreciate NOW where we have probably left the likes of the undeniably talented rohan sippy behind,..
    So let’s have some takes
    And Amy : no EMET / student of the year stuff here plz 🙂

    Like

    • Not sure who that ‘we’ constitutes but I guess I’m not part of this club!

      Like

      • “Not sure who that ‘we’ constitutes but I guess I’m not part of this club!”
        Haha Satyam: u have been unknowingly ‘lured’ into a different part of the jungle
        So can u/anyone put rohan sippy or such ilk amongst these four gentlemen..

        Like

    • Hmm adoor is quite a good choice-not many can contest it
      Thigh those same should be asked how many of adoors films they’ve seen and then the plot will thicken !!
      Let’s have a poll
      For someone with as good as credentials as adoor, WHY the marbles couldn’t he get a bit more accessible even like maniratnam
      Even I have /can make exquisitelt auteuristic ‘home videos’ seen by a cocktail ish orgy-ish cohort but that doesn’t amount to much..
      There has to be a bare minimum accessibility /reach beyond festival circuits etc
      For that reason IMO adoor is probably not even in the big4- just my opinion …

      Like

      • “For someone with as good as credentials as adoor, WHY the marbles couldn’t he get a bit more accessible even like maniratnam”

        I’ve often wondered why Bach didn’t sell as many albums as Michael Jackson.

        On Adoor regrettably I’ve only seen 4 or so films (though he hasn’t made that many).

        and yes people make Adoor-like efforts all the time in their garages. Plus you can’t expect him to come upto Coktail-like standards. That’s too high a bar.

        Like

      • “For that reason IMO adoor is probably not even in the big4- just my opinion …”

        Yes, it must be difficult to make room for Adoor what with the likes of the venerable Milan Luthria giving him competition.

        Like

        • Milan luthria is not in the top20 (forget top4)-lets not get distracted lol
          The top4 is as above …(only)

          Like

  67. Haha
    Don’t wanna the undeniably genius adoor,
    But I think he fails to make the mark due to accessibility, reach..
    Unlike some other forms of art, this assessment is for films made for others (other than the director/technical team/co auteurs)
    Ok, lets have a poll of those here
    Obviously this is a highly NONrepresentive sample concisitong of film enthusiasts etc (of above average ‘tastes/intelligence ‘ hopefully
    All would have seen some film of thee four
    How many have seen adoors films (barring satyam /gf)
    Raise your ….s guys
    And also anjali/any/oldgold etc -how many have seen adoors films?

    Like

    • Alex, now might be a good time to stop digging!

      Like

    • As long as you’re only excluding Satyam/GF. I’ve seen 8 (Elippathayam, Mukhamukham, Mathilukal, Naalu Pennungal, Kodiyettam, Swayamvaram, Anantharam and Nizhalkkuthu)- obviously I hold him in quite high esteem

      Like

      • Wow chip guy …hmm
        Most hold him in high esteem-(those who know him/his films)
        Whos the greatest Indian filmmaker alive in your opinion though ..

        Like

      • I hope you went to a ‘normal’ theater for these CG..

        Like

        • As “normal” as theatres in Kerala in the late 80s were 🙂

          Like

        • Alex says no theater in Kerala counts as normal! He’s one of those who feel that South Indians pull out that old South Indian card on the rest of India! Watching films in Kerala is a dirty South Indian ethnic trick!

          Like

  68. Haha 🙂
    I maintain my point though respect your choice of adoor…

    Like

  69. rockstar Says:

    Moutatthu “Adoor” Gopalakrishnan Unnithan (born 3 July 1941) is an Indian film director, script writer, and producer. Adoor Gopalakrishnan had a major role in revolutionizing Malayalam cinema and is regarded as one of the greatest filmmakers of India.[1] Adoor’s first film Swayamvaram (1972) pioneered the new wave cinema movement in Kerala. Most of his films go to festivals around the world, and are released in Kerala. All the eleven films he directed, from Swayamvaram to Oru Pennum Randaanum (2008), were screened at several international film festivals and won him several national and international awards. He won National Film Awards sixteen times, Kerala State Film Awards seventeen times and also won several international film awards. He won the prestigious British Film Institute award for Elippathayam (1981). Adoor received the Padma Shri in 1984 and the Padma Vibhushan in 2006. The Nation honoured Adoor for his valuable contributions to Indian cinema by awarding him the highest cinema award of India, the Dadasaheb Phalke Award for the year 2004.[2]

    Like

    • “Most of his films go to festivals around the world, and are released in Kerala”
      Hmm well, I’m sure Satyam is mature enough to rise above the narrow ‘state’ affiliations etc (Kerala) 🙂

      Like

      • Yes because we know that Ray only has the reputation he has because all of those Bengalis that are simply unable to rise above their state affiliation. Where do you come up with this stuff?!

        Like

        • Was pulling Satyams leg 🙂
          These folks like ray/adoor are universal
          It’s just that most mortals haven’t seen that part of the ‘universe’ to judge/compare accurately…

          Like

        • Adoor films are difficult to come by and even when one finds one a subtitled version isn’t guaranteed. But there’s no excuse to not see Ray at least on the grounds of accessibility to prints of the films themselves. Interest though is another matter.

          Like

  70. Hmm thanx for that cut /paste job rockstar
    Who is your choice though
    Ps: to watch adoor, who will employ a ‘language coach’ 🙂
    That’s another issue haahha

    Like

  71. tonymontana Says:

    Ive tried my best in staying away from making my list due to an inferiority complex (list might be ridiculed), but ill try.. apologies for not having watched a lot many films of the greats but ill make an effort, just to stay in the limelight. Pardon me:

    Hindi film directors:

    Hrishikesh Mukherjee
    Raj Kapoor
    Shekhar Kapoor
    Vijay Anand
    Manmohan Desai
    Raj Kumar Hirani
    The early RGV
    Raj Kumar Santoshi
    Anurag Kashyap
    Dibakar Banerjee
    Vishal Bhardwaj

    Hollywood / Word Cinema:

    Kubrick
    Scorsese
    Tarantino
    Spielberg
    Hitchcock
    Hayao miyazaki

    Like

    • A very good list tony!!
      Balanced with a capital ‘b’
      Am impressed to see shekhar kapoor, vijay anand , kashyap besides some usual suspects
      Who is the greatest Indian filmmaker alive(active) though …

      Like

    • tonymontana Says:

      i have pather panchali since eons in my system 😦 keep procrastinating
      satyajit ray will make the list though just coz of his one Charulata. ! however I need to see more films.. Grrrrrrr

      Like

    • tonymontana Says:

      Damn! I forgot to include Polanski

      Like

    • Good lists here Tony.. there’s no reason to feel inferior. One has always seen more than someone and less than someone else.

      Like

      • Of course we are average viewers (propably little better) and you are an outlier 😉

        I hardly see any movie because someone has directed it.

        ps – Last night saw Sherlock Holmes – A Game of Shadows , American Reunion 🙂

        Like

        • “you are an outlier ;)”

          that’s the polite way of putting it. I’m a sicko in these matters (some would say others too) and no one should aspire to this state!

          Like

        • compared to some people I know, including Sam, who is here occasionally, I am a slouch, believe it or not! He probably watches 200 films in the theaters every years! Won’t even get into the home-viewing!

          Like

      • tonymontana Says:

        thanks satyam

        Like

    • Great to see Miyazaki on your list Tony! 🙂 What’s your film of his?

      “Ive tried my best in staying away from making my list due to an inferiority complex”

      Why do you have an inferiority complex?! You’re one of the most mature, balanced people on SS IMO- and I always enjoy reading your thoughts on various films.

      Like

      • tonymontana Says:

        thank you so much ami..

        Spirited Away would top all animation Ive ever seen. seriously. despite the Pixar films being superior in animation (though I doubt there’s much to say on that front) dwarf in comparison to this.. Ive also tremendously enjoyed My Neighbour Totoro

        Like

        • I may be the only one saying this but Toy Story 3 is arguably the greatest animated film ever IMO. In my list (from the ones i can remember currently) it will be closely followed by Wallace And Gromit. The other favs in no order are Prince of Egypt, Ponyo, Iron Giant, Cast Away, Up, The Incredibles, Titan A.E., Waltz With Bashir, A Bug’s Life, Persepolis, Happy Feet, Finding Nemo, Alladin, How To Train Your Dragon, A Cat In Paris, Wall E

          Like

        • I loved Toy Story 3. Think it’s the best one in the franchise. Extraordinary in very many ways. Certainly one of the summits in animation.

          Like

        • Toy Story 3 is a masterwork, and easily the best of the series. My single favorite Pixar movie and by quite a stretch. I think I’d make a case for Waltz with Bashir as the greatest animated film though this is a bit of a cop-out given the genre and the subject matter it takes on isn’t really comparable with mainstream animated efforts from any part of the world. When the Wind Blows is also up there…the Miyazaki works are terrific though I’m not as keen on all of them as most folks seem to be.

          Like

        • I like TS3 very much. My favorite of that year and I am not a fan of animated movies.

          Like

        • I think that Toy Story 3 is a great animated film- but I have to agree with Tony that the best of Miyazaki’s films dwarf almost everything else.

          Like

  72. rockstar Says:

    yes highest cinema award of india when shekhar kapoor was busy glamorizing phoolan devi’s life when she didn’t give recognition and intent on selling sleaze and her best acheivment a crass dress drama unlike someonelike satyajit ray who revolutionised indian film making

    Like

  73. Rockstar- your views are welcome but ray is no longer alive
    ( unfortunately ) ….lol

    Like

  74. Btw just checking–
    How many adoor films have u seen rockstar, tony….

    Like

  75. rockstar Says:

    for the record mr india was one of the last salim-javed script right

    some cult indian maestro who are the benchmark( and the refrence has always been trendsetter)

    1. satyajit ray

    2. shyam benegal ( revolutionised art cinema making which is evident from today’s wannabe dark cinema patron like kashyap, banerjee.)

    3 hrishikesh mukherjee( who can inspire hirani as well shetty’s and sajid the extreme

    4. mani ratnam ( for giving maximum new talent to indian cinema)

    5. guru dutt ( its evident with how his movie aged with time)

    of the contemporaries none have made any revolutionary cinema as such

    Like

    • speaking of Guru Dutt I was revisiting his Aar paar the other day and all of the director’s visual sophistication is available in abundance here (unlike say Mr & Mrs 55). Remarkable frames throughout the work. Leaving aside the great films and something like Baazi I think Aar Paar might be most impressive on this score. But I’d even go further and say that in some ways Guru Dutt is even more inventive and spontaneous here than on those greater works. referring only to the visuals.

      Like

      • rockstar Says:

        yup remarkable use of camera and lights …his films had always been visual delights

        still its quite fascinatiing see the use of frames by him ….these are his film before he got his bigger recognition but one can’t ignore technical brilliance on that

        Like

  76. ^ again only one /two in this list are actually ‘alive’ rockstar 🙂

    Like

  77. rockstar Says:

    aa: 2 if i haven’t not much then its the fault of indian main stream who can’t go along and provide regional cinema to others

    like satyajit ray adoor has the credit of being torch bearer of indian cinema when bollywood was making trash in 80’s and 90’s ….infact rate him on par with ray

    Like

  78. rockstar Says:

    alive or death has hardly anything to do with shelf life and its basic commonsense

    Like

    • Haha if one starts including dead folks also-lists will be difficult
      Lists should have a basic ‘criteria’
      Here we were restricting to alive ones
      But if u insist, u can add ray n other such as a ‘tribute’ 🙂

      Like

      • rockstar Says:

        tribute i thought it was all about mocking others

        may be COCKtake or an european style of docu drama may do wonder but thats not different from desi directors like shetty or half breed sajid

        has imtiaz shown any versatility apart from romance genre( a same film made by 3 times) or for that matter zoya which nothing in filmography

        Like

        • rockstar Says:

          those who like them from new lot:

          rgv

          hirani

          gowariker

          prakash jha

          vishal bhadwaj

          kashyap( had to come out from his hostel type fascination and made something big)

          bhansali

          but there is not one standout among these or special

          like rohan sippy and farhan akhtar (the urban class representation)

          sujoy ghosh if he plays to his stength and sridhar raghvan to

          Like

        • rockstar Says:

          for the record just try to compare record of zoya baby/imtiaz to shimit amin ( ab tak chappan and chak de india are the two most impactful movie in desi themes of recent time but ya he is not blowing his own trumpet)

          Like

        • Lol @ COCKtake
          Can understand your emotions mate, but there are kids/girls around 😉
          They will get ‘scared’ hahaa

          Like

  79. someone pls comeup with a list of the 10 greatest westerns of all time. saw searchers and fell in love with this genre.searchers is a great movie….its lot better than any made by leone.
    pls ensure that the list should have those films which best evoke the world of the 19th century usa…..and the characters speak and behave like they must have done in the 19th century with a rustic animation and have deep seated patriarchal values and prejudices..a director who has to sensibility to pull that off.

    one thing which really pisses me off whenever i see a historical movie…is the way man woman relationship is portrayed.they make these relationships look too modern and liberal….which i dont think should be the case.

    Like

    • my list in no order would be…

      1)Searchers
      2)Good the Bad and the Ugly
      3)Once upon a time in the West
      4)Outlaw Josey Wales
      5)Red River
      6)The Naked Spur (though The Far Country, Winchester ’73 and maybe a couple of others from this director are at the same level)
      7)Ulzana’s Raid
      8)Fort Apache
      9)Man who shot Liberty Valance
      10)My Darling Clementine

      This is just a list off the top of my head. High Noon is one of the most iconic Westerns as is Shane though neither one is a favorite of mine. With Ford you can watch just about any of his Westerns. Same with Leone. Hawks has a couple of good ones besides Red River. Some directors who were otherwise not specialists of the genre attempted it successfully. There’s Canyon Passage (Tourneur, otherwise best known for Out of the Past) for example.

      Anyway I’m sure I’m missing out on a number of interesting ones. More recently I liked the 3:10 to Yuma remake a lot. and of course the original could be on a top 10 as well.

      Like

  80. Anjali: hope u are ok? Haha
    Westerns hmm…lol Sergio leone..
    Once u are thru this phase, can u teach me /summarise for me pleez 🙂
    Ps-“is the way man woman relationship is portrayed.they make these relationships look too modern and liberal….which i dont think should be the case”–hmm..will talk to them about this…

    Like

  81. 😉

    Like

  82. Farhan Akhtar has been a disappointment as a director. There are so many other contemporary directors who I rate higher than him (Just for fun started making a list and came up with these names: Raju Hirani, Rakesh Mehra, Vishal Bhardwaj, Ashutosh Gowarikar, Sriram Raghavan, Shimit Amin, Sanjay Leela Bhansali, Imtiaz Ali, Anurag Kashyap, Rohan Sippy, Diwakar Baneerjee.)

    Farhan should be named Mr.Perfectly Average: average director, average actor, middling star, poor singer, poor lyricist, poor TV anchor…well even that name seems to be doing him a favor!

    Like

    • Farhan has done pretty much worse with every film. Having said that Lakshya despite the conformist and uninteresting second half has some dazzling visuals.

      Like

      • After the superb DCH in 2001, Farhan has wasted the next decade making Lakshya and the two snoozefests called Don 1 and Don2. I’d really expected much more from him. There is a sense of drift to his directorial career, his strongest suit by far. He seems to have lost his identity as a filmmaker. Ironically he may need to take a coming-of-age-vacation ala ZNMD to get his groove back.

        Like

  83. Just finished watching King Of Comedy by Scorcese. One of the most inspirational movie of all time.
    Bravo!
    The best of Scorcese after Taxi Driver.The movie is truly inspiring,all the black comedy ends up not making fun of Rupert Pupkin (the main protagonist)….as I was expecting,but ended up making fun of the viewers!
    To sum the film in one sentence…I would quote William Blake:

    “If a man persists in his folly,he will become wise.”

    Like

  84. Thanx for that succinct summary anjali : cheers 🙂

    Like

  85. tonymontana Says:

    Satyam n others,

    what do you think of the only Hindi film Ray ever made – Shatranj ke Khiladi?

    Like

    • It’s a good film but nowhere close to his great works. I’d even take most of his lesser Bengali works over it.

      On that note I’m a naysayer on his Home and the World. Except for this beautiful number which is the rare patriotic song (if not the only one) I like:

      Like

      • tonymontana Says:

        thanks for sharing n sharing the video satyam..

        Perhaps that explains why Im least looking forward to SKK.. Which might still be better than most Hindi films.. well, I guess there isnt even an comparison.

        Like

        • Shatranj Ke Khiladi is the only Ray film i have seen and i am a fan of it. Though it often makes mistakes regarding facts (Doctrine of Lapse etc), it has the most accurate portrayal of Awadh (Oudh) and my hometown Lucknow.

          Like

        • it’s based on a Premchand story.

          Like

        • “which is the rare patriotic song (if not the only one) I like”- Satyam i am surprised to know this. For example how can u not like Rafi’s “Ab Tumhare Hawale Watan Saathiyon” (Haqeeqat)- imo it’s one of the best songs ever in any language. Easily my fav Rafi song alonwith Ye Duniya Agar Mil Bhi Jaye and Yeh Galiyaan Yeh Chaubara.

          Like

        • I like the tune there but just not one for patriotic fervor!

          Like

        • a good film to watch right after Shatranj… is Shashi Kapoor’s Junoon (Benegal).

          Like

        • Yes, i have read the novel though it’s not my fav Premchand work- Kafan remains my fav. Junoon is my fav Benegal film. In fact i will go on to say that it’s the best bollywood adaptation of a novel. Ruskin Bond (since he lives in Mussourie) himself came to our school and we saw the film with him. I think it has brilliant cinematography too. And again this has the best portrayal of the Rohilkhand region. And alongwith New Delhi Times and Vijeta this remains my favourite Shashi performance

          Like

      • Do you mean Ghare Baire? Why are you a naysayer on it?

        Like

        • Find it to be a fairly ordinary film and though some of it is the source material (it’s a great Tagore classic of course but not necessarily the profoundest one) it’s also the case that Ray in his last decade or more ceased to an interesting visual artist. I like his last work, Agantuk (the Stranger), a lot but again the camerawork is really functional here as well. The important Ray is really capped off by the Middleman in the mid-70s. Don’t mean this as a knock. No one can go on forever and Ray has by my count 12-15 essential films which is more than I can say for many other great filmmakers. But after the mid-70s one really sees his movies for ‘completion’ purposes, again with the exception of the Stranger for me. Do know that Ghare Baire is regarded as one of the ‘essentials’ by most of his ‘native’ audience.

          Like

        • I haven’t seen too many Ray films- but Ghare Baire is one of my favourites. I thought that it was a very visually interesting film in a spatial sense- similar to Charulatha- I’m nowhere near knowledgeable enough to engage in a debate about Ray’s visual artistry with you 😛 but here is a very interesting article that argues my point far more intelligently than I ever could-

          http://www.jmionline.org/film_journal/jmi_06/article_09.php

          Like

        • will check out this piece later but I will check out Home and the World soon. You might well be right, I might have missed something here.

          Like

        • rockstar Says:

          yup age had catched up on him but seriously agantuk still had content ajay devgan loosely remaked it as athithi tum kab jaoge by taking out all intellectual element

          don’t see middleman( one of the real fav) as final knock as feluda series as thrillers where equally competent in terms of story telling…fact is even his mediocre work where better than most of best

          Like

        • Don’t get me wrong, Ray is one of the most watchable directors even on a poor day. Of the two Feluda films he did I like Sonar Kella but this came out before Middleman. And even this though a compulsive watch isn’t the equal of Middleman.

          Like

        • rockstar Says:

          satyam :

          http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=middleman+satyajit+ray+&oq=middleman+satyajit+ray+&gs_l=youtube.3…576.1945.0.2325.8.7.0.0.0.0.0.0..0.0…0.0…1ac.

          (subtitles are there in movie itself)

          Like

        • thanks I do have this on DVD.. I wanted to revisit Ghare Baire though which too I have but the youtube transfer seems cleaner. Unfortunately it doesn’t have subs.

          Like

        • rockstar Says:

          why should i get you wrong lol

          his later half work where good but certainly pales in front of his earlier one surely

          joy baba felunath was not that bad and even agantuk and western press even hails those as brilliant

          http://movies.nytimes.com/movie/review?res=9E0CE3DB163EF931A15756C0A964958260&partner=Rotten%20Tomatoes

          Like

        • rockstar Says:

          btw thanks for recommending jalsagar and araneyar din ratri ….both are gems and so do mahanagar (the debut of jaya bachchan)

          Like

    • @tony
      I liked Shatranj ke khilari.
      It was a ‘hatke’ film for Ray.
      To have created awadh like that. It satisfied my ‘period film’ tastes completely.

      The only negative thing about it is that the ending was changed from that of the short story by Munshi Premchand. By changing this, much of the impact of the story was lost, but otherwise it was a film of Ray standards alright.
      The actors were brilliant, and Amjad Khan got to act a role different from what he normally did.

      Like

  86. tonymontana Says:

    Lol. Satyam. just read your comment somewhere above of being a sicko in these matters.

    Looks to me you eat, sleep and breathe films all day long.
    I suspect you might have a career related to films. Do you teach at a film institute, or own one, by any chance?

    Like

    • I have never been in the business of corrupting people so no I don’t teach anywhere. As for owning a film institute haven’t quite been able to spare a couple of hours for this but will do so the moment I can.

      Like

      • I have always wondered what would happen to Satyam if one fine day his wife/gf (assuming that he is not single) turns out to be an SRK fan and to her horror ends up checking out the criticism SRK gets at the hands of Satyam and few others on this blog. That would be the day 🙂

        Like

        • Men with taste also select women with taste..

          Then again I might not have taste in which case your scenario could potentially arise..

          Usually it’s the mother-in-law one has to worry about. They poison you if you say anything negative on SRK.

          Like

      • tonymontana Says:

        So that is on your mind after all? wow – now thats interesting! unless I missed sarcasm in your tone..

        Like

        • Just kidding Tony.. I can’t open an institute in a couple of hours. Give me 3 and maybe..

          Like

        • Tony,
          Satyam I presume doesn’t like to be tied down by these kinds of things. He even shuns any kind of fame and/or prestige. But he is going to find out to his horror that he will be wallowing in it when AOL offers to buy him out 5 years from now for a princely sum as the Huff post acquisition hasn’t really moved their stock price. This will be AOLs entree in to Bollywood blogosphere and the analyst selling stories of a billion plus people will finally move AOL stock. For Satyam of course nothing will change except his bank balance and I suspect GF and Q will leave their day jobs and write full time for this blog 🙂

          Like

        • Ha, Pranav, thereafter I shall wake up!

          Like

        • Not completely implausible. Look at Nikki Finkes Deadline Hollywood.

          Like

  87. tonymontana Says:

    lol saurabh. I think satyam will be the best person to answer this – which films / actors does his better half / girlfriend admire?

    Like

  88. i was downloading a 12gb tv version of fanny and alexander.it is a 6 hr original version of the film by bergman.my speed is not that fast…for the past day and a half i have been downloading it….uninterrupted.
    and i was thinking i will watch it…and i was like 200 mb away from completing it.
    hours and hours of labor was finally going to bear fruit.
    and by mistake i cancelled the download.
    all is lostttttttttttttttttttt!
    and now there r no seeders left of that tv series.
    its goneeeeeeeeeeee!
    there is nooooo justice in this wicked world.i hate god!
    can i kill someone to change my mood?

    Like

      • The most satirical…..
        The most sarcastic…..
        The most black humorish and cynical sentence that MAN ever came up with is:
        ALWAYS LOOK AT THE BRIGHT SIDE OF LIFE.

        Just found out there is a song dedicated to this line.

        hope you guys will enjoy this song from your cross as i am doing it from mine.
        “life is a piece of shit
        when you look at it”

        Like

        • The word ‘pessimist’ wasn’t coined for nothing 😉

          Like

        • Another view of the world.

          I guess the reality is somewhere in between.

          Like

        • what a wonderful song!
          wished the song never ended and became my life.

          Like

        • I haven’t read the article, but the so called ‘third world’ has physical and material problems whereas the ‘west’ has very very big mental problems.

          Problems are problems no matter what kind.

          Like

        • It’s not an article- and the term is not to be taken in the political sense. ‘First world problems’ is just a slang term that indicates very trivial problems that seem enormous because of the lives of relative privilege that some people lead.

          Like

        • And just to be clear- I meant that link as a joke, not a criticism. I’ve been frustrated when I’ve accidentally cancelled a download as well- but I’m just trying to provide some perspective here.

          Like

  89. LOL !!!

    In 1941, a year after his movie, The Great McGinty, won the first ever Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay, celebrated screenwriter/director and “father of the screwball comedy,” Preston Sturges, drew up the following “eleven rules for box-office appeal.”

    (Source: The Cinema of Preston Sturges: A Critical Study; Image: Preston Sturges, via PBS.)

    A pretty girl is better than an ugly one.
    A leg is better than an arm.
    A bedroom is better than a living room.
    An arrival is better than a departure.
    A birth is better than a death.
    A chase is better than a chat.
    A dog is better than a landscape.
    A kitten is better than a dog.
    A baby is better than a kitten.
    A kiss is better than a baby.
    A pratfall is better than anything.

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.