Review of PIRANHA 3D
Dying to get wet
Piranha 3D
Dir– Alexandre Aja
Cast– Elisabeth Shue, Steven R. McQueen, Jerry O’Connell, Kelly Brook, Adam Scott, Jessica Szohr and Ving Rhames
Rating– ** ½
Piranha 3D is virtually an unreviewable film. In its brisk running time of 88 minutes, not once does the film try to make any pretense of having any whatsoever cinematic merit. And yet, director Alexandre Aja delivers on the promise of dishing out an orgy of bodies and blood and nothing more. For once, the star rating above does not reflect the recommendation of this critic. If you’re a fan of the cult & cheesy 1978 Roger Corman Piranha, and its low-budget 1981 sequel Piranha II: The Spawning that launched the directing career of one James Cameron… Aja’s remake and franchise-reboot is exactly what you should be watching.
In a movie then that doesn’t have a plot, except in the form of a narrative that is an excuse for wink-wink nods to previous films of the genre and an opportunity for its assortment of bikini-clad women to flash their assets before the titular fish unleash their carnage… Piranha 3D gleefully begins with Richard Dreyfuss gamely reprising his role from the Spielberg classic Jaws. Fishing on a still-water sunny day, singing Show Me The Way To Go Home; an earthquake causes the bottom of the lake that he’s sailing atop to split and release in its whirlpool thousands of prehistoric piranhas that had existed beneath the chasm. Meanwhile, at a nearby lake-town, Spring Break has meant hundreds of oversexed and intoxicated teenagers going hedonistically unruly. Insert- random footage of wet t-shirts and bubble-thongs! Before the local Sheriff Julie (Elisabeth Shue) can declare the lake shut however, the piranhas gatecrash the party and have their own private feast.
Aja, whose previous films The Hills Have Eyes and Mirrors were also remakes, stays true to the spirit of the campy Corman original. So even as you’re terrified watching a school of piranhas collectively gnaw at the private parts of a woman lazing on a float, you guffaw as a piranha spits out the silicone implants of a stripper that it has devoured. There’s also the rather crude variety of poetic justice when a single-mindedly horny pornographer meets his end by way of his organ being chewed off! If any of this is putting you off, Piranha 3D is not for you. But if you’re a fan of torture-films like Hostel– heck, Hostel director Eli Roth pops up in a cameo as well, meeting an end that is grisly even by his standards -Aja’s curious blend of all-out gore and as much soft-core as the envelope can push is mighty fun.
Besides, this is perhaps the first film since Cameron’s Avatar where the 3D doesn’t look like a last-minute add-on. Right from the opening credits to the booty-grind at the lake and then the ultimate bloodbath… the film looks to have been shot with the 3D conversion in mind. Apart from obvious 3D gimmicks like having a character vomit on the screen to a whip being lashed in your face, Aja also makes exploitative use of 3D to enhance the contours of female anatomy- best exemplified in an underwater naked lesbian ballet!
Curse the Indian Censor Board for chopping the explicit skin-show but retaining the gory dismemberments. Guess the natural sight of breasts are more offensive than the insides of a person hanging out from the torso! Guess that’s the point that Aja’s trying to make by blurring the lines between bodies and blood? Nah… that’s reading too much! It’s fish eating half-naked chicks… and it’s fun!
– Abhishek Bandekar
31/10/10
November 2, 2010 at 7:53 AM
This made for a fun read Abzee even if I utterly detested the movie! Two comments from earlier:
“just saw this and I must say it would be at or near the top of my list for sickest film ever! Total garbage. Here’s a moment that’s most symptomatic of the film. Guy gets half eaten, yells he’s lost his organ, a little later we see the ‘homunculus’ floating around in the water only to be gorged in turn! Semi-nude women every other second, the 3D is rather poorly done, it’s just a miserable film. Now I’m a fan of this wider genre (animals eating people!) but this was a repellent film! I remember watching Snakes on a plane and finding it atrocious but that was a classic compared to this!”
“oh you’ll certainly get lots of girls here in every conceivable kind of undress! You even get two ‘mermaiding’ underwater!
This actually got fairly positive critical attention as many critics assimilated it to older ‘exploitation’ paradigms. Of course there was the classic conservative Hollywood message here. The spring lake party which more or less resembled an orgy. You see a couple of people holding up the bible. The piranha here are ‘ancient’ types, a kind of revenge visited upon the decadent humans.”
LikeLike
November 2, 2010 at 7:59 AM
This film is quite truly the absolute pits of filmmaking, or atleast the pits in terms of what purpose one wishes to serve by the employment of the medium. And while the critical evaluation of this overall has been puzzling, I guess they’re confusing having a good time (questionable tastes, myself guilty!) with being a good film. I know this is bad filmmaking, but within that, it strangely seemed to deliver upon its promise. It’s like a cornerstreet drug peddler who sells aphrodisiacs!
LikeLike
November 2, 2010 at 8:01 AM
Ha!
LikeLike
November 2, 2010 at 8:04 AM
I happened to interview the director of this film btw, should put it up.
LikeLike
November 2, 2010 at 8:03 AM
Of course there was the classic conservative Hollywood message here. The spring lake party which more or less resembled an orgy. You see a couple of people holding up the bible. The piranha here are ‘ancient’ types, a kind of revenge visited upon the decadent humans.”
Wes Craven’s Scream rightly pointed the rules of the slasher/creature-feature genre. The virgin girl never dies… it is always the racial minority and the sinful slut that die first. Piranha 3D carries on that disturbing subtext!
LikeLike
November 2, 2010 at 8:08 AM
On a slightly unrelated note, compared to Clash Of The Titans, Alice In Wonderland and The Last Airbender… the 3D conversion here was fairly good I felt. There was no blurring, discolouration or the scenes looking underlit… as is the case with RealD conversions that happen as an afterthought in post. This looked to have been shot with twin-camera 3D rigs and lit with the 3D conversion in mind.
LikeLike
November 2, 2010 at 8:17 AM
But there was some distortion of scale at points..
LikeLike
November 2, 2010 at 7:39 PM
Ace review…have been meaning to write my own on this film for a while, but I enjoyed this quite a bit because it promised what it delivered….and then some!
LikeLike
November 3, 2010 at 5:00 AM
Not great movie making…just plain old guilty pleasure :D!
LikeLike
August 21, 2011 at 4:31 PM
lol..this was a fun watch till too much of dismemberments took all the fun away 🙂
LikeLike
August 21, 2011 at 6:30 PM
heh heh..
Speaking of dismemberments I saw Final Destination 5 (3D). I’m a great fan of this franchise. I thought this was a bit better than ‘4’. But the eyeball scene is nonetheless hard to watch (as the reviewers suggested).
LikeLike
May 12, 2012 at 9:56 AM
Satyam, trailer of Piranha 3DD (sequel to Piranha 3D). US release date- June 1, 2012
Cast- Danielle Panabaker, Matt Bush, David Koechner, Chris Zylka, Katrina Bowden, Gary Busey, Christopher Lloyd, and David Hasselhoff. Director- John Gulagar
LikeLike
May 12, 2012 at 11:15 AM
check out the first response in this thread..!
LikeLike
May 12, 2012 at 11:18 AM
Oh, I hadn’t read it. Probably shouldn’t have put the trailer. will take care in the future
LikeLike
May 12, 2012 at 11:39 AM
that’s fine.. others can watch it!
LikeLike
May 12, 2012 at 11:43 AM
Satyam, I was confused, what kind of trailers should I put, I mean which deserve to be put here. I often realise that a lot of good important films just release and that their trailers have not been put up here, this is simply my view but i believe people may want to know abt those films
LikeLike
May 12, 2012 at 11:45 AM
Q: Satyam, I was confused, what kind of trailers should I put, I mean which deserve to be put here.
A: p.o.r.n. 🙂
LikeLike
May 12, 2012 at 11:46 AM
I love the Hentai variety, which one is ur fav?
LikeLike
May 12, 2012 at 11:51 AM
haha no comments right now (am working)–but will revisit this topic later maybe….
hahahaha rofl
“just saw this and I must say it would be at or near the top of my list for sickest film ever! Total garbage. Here’s a moment that’s most symptomatic of the film. Guy gets half eaten, yells he’s lost his organ, a little later we see the ‘homunculus’ floating around in the water only to be gorged in turn! Semi-nude women every other second, the 3D is rather poorly done, it’s just a miserable film. Now I’m a fan of this wider genre (animals eating people!) but this was a repellent film! I remember watching Snakes on a plane and finding it atrocious but that was a classic compared to this!”
“oh you’ll certainly get lots of girls here in every conceivable kind of undress! You even get two ‘mermaiding’ underwater!
LikeLike
June 26, 2012 at 8:02 PM
Did a crime- Saw “PIRANHA 3DD” in the theatre and that also in 3D. Now i had quite liked the preceding film (and the earlier 2 films) and i am a fan of this genre (which seems to be dead) but this was the worst hollywood film i have seen in years. Now i know that these films do not care about story etc but atleast they should have a narrative, this one was devoid of even a narrative- it seemed like a combination of disjointed scenes which were shamefully bad. and this is not even ‘kitschy fun’
LikeLike
June 26, 2012 at 8:14 PM
And the 3D was horrible. the film was neither gory enough nor did it deliver on the promised ‘eye candy’ aspect- there is one bright spot where Baywatch star Davil Hasselhof, in a cameo, spoofs himself as a celebrity lifeguard. And a ‘creative’ scene where a piranha, which was previously lodged in a girl’s vagina, bites her boyfriend’s organ while they are having sex. Rest of the film is unwatchable. anyway i wasted my 90 bucks on this
LikeLike
May 12, 2012 at 11:56 AM
For ALex, Trailer of Jean Dujar starrer and directed by Artist filmmaker Michael Hazanivicius and 4 other directors-french film- “Les Infideles” (the players).
Directed by Emmanuelle Bercot
Michel Hazanavicius
Jean Dujardin[1]
Gilles Lellouche
Series of vignettes about the theme of male infidelity and its adulterous variants.
LikeLike
May 12, 2012 at 12:53 PM
I see abzee cursing the Indian censor board for its double-standards. Watched 21 Jump Streep recently at a theatre near me and there was a supposedly comic scene where Jonah Hill shoots a guy in his dick and it falls off. they show the dismembered organ lying on the street but for some reason a scene where a guy makes out with a woman (no nude body parts – just making out) was cut. this thing remained in mind for some time but didnt express it.
LikeLike
May 12, 2012 at 1:44 PM
And they didn’t even let The Gurl With The Dragon Tattoo release in India! Yet- they’ll give a film like Ra.One a ‘Universal’ certificate and let SRK Market it as a children’s film- BTW it had a 12 rating in the UK and a PG-13 rating in the USA.
LikeLike