Notable cinematographers on their films

thanks to Bliss..
LINK

Rajiv Menon on Bombay

Mani Ratnam’s Tamil film Bombay, which was released along with a dubbed Hindi version in 1993, is a film with two distinct sections. The first is a rapturous romance between a Brahmin man and a Muslim woman. The second follows the couple as they move to Mumbai, raise a family and get trapped in the 1992-’93 communal riots. Bombay was shot by advertising filmmaker and cinematographer Rajiv Menon, who also worked on Ratnam’s Guru in 2007, in addition to directing two of his own films (Minsaru Kanavu and Kandukondain Kandukondain).

What discussions did you have with Mani Ratnam before shooting Bombay?
Mani Ratnam told me that Bombay was going to be about the riots and that we would see a lot of the riots. So we needed to make what came before the riots as beautiful as possible. I suggested that we shoot in the rains and he said, okay.

We shot in different places and put them all together. The interiors of the homes were in Pollachi in Tamil Nadu. The exteriors were in Kasargod in Kerala. The first half has a lot of blues. I remember watching British films shot in winter that would set navy blue against green.

How did you visually recreate Mumbai and the riots?
We had to create the city of Bombay on two streets! We got away with some scenes set at night. That’s why I had so many burning tyres. I based the Bombay bits on my own experiences in the city. We used the city’s landmarks such as the Gateway of India and Marina Drive. You have to put flags down for audiences to identify the city.

All we had [to recreate the riots] were several photographs. I kept a book of these photographs – this was before television. After all, cinematic visuals stem not just from other cinematic visuals but from books, paintings and photographs. One of the visuals I remember was of a Muslim victim lying with his head smashed on a floor, surrounded by slippers.

There are some deeply sensuous camera movements in both the romance as well as the songs.
The camera moves a lot – there would be long takes followed by three-four small cuts. It made lighting continuity easier for me and I was able to move fluidly. The exposure became dynamic and formed a pattern – you moved from light to patches of darkness again to light.

You can condense a lot of emotions in a song. Songs have a narrative aspect in Indian cinema, something that has been forgotten. A song has been reduced to a celebration. However, some songs can capture a sense of exhilaration in other ways – look at “Aaj Phir Jeene Ki Tamanna Hai” from Guide or “Chhaiyya Chhaiyya” from Dil Se.

Mani and I share a fascination for the way Guru Dutt shot his songs. Satyajit Ray too had an understanding of the sensuous quality of Indian music. “Kannalane” [“Kehna Hi Kya” in Hindi] is full of incongruities. It is set in what looks like a mosque. Or “Uyire” [“Tu Hi Re”]. The emotion of love being communicated is so strong that you believe that the hero is willing to die for the heroine.

for more follow the link..

14 Responses to “Notable cinematographers on their films”

  1. Looks to be a very interesting read.. will get to it later. Did read the Menon bit. The shot I’ve selected here is one of scores of remarkable ones in the film. It’s a movie where I love the first 60% or so but it loses focus very quickly after this. Because Ratnam makes a ‘subject’ out of the riots and the problem is that he doesn’t really have a proper character to lead us through these ‘chaotic’ bits (which are still filmed impressively). I also didn’t care for his very easy resolution (though he had to remove a few controversial bits). But in that first half or two-thirds of the film I think has as good an ‘introduction’ to late-Ratnam as any. Overall still have a great weakness for it.

    Like

  2. Related to this : Planning for Opening Titles

    Like

  3. OT,

    Roger Ebert latest list of 10 greatest films for Sight N sound poll

    http://blogs.suntimes.com/ebert/2012/04/the_greatest_films_of_all_time.html

    Like

  4. There is such a wealth of great information in this. It’s always such a pleasure to hear from Indian cinematographers. Their interviews are more often than not more informed, insightful and interesting than the filmmakers they work for!

    Several passages standout here. There’s Hemant Chaturvedi’s point about Company’s lamentable video transfer – always thought this was underexposed and didn’t match the theater print by a long shot. Heartening also to see a couple of voices heralding Venu’s cinematography. Muraleedharan’s descriptions of the rigs he built during Johnny Gadaar, Binod Pradhan shedding some light on a film I otherwise don’t care for very much (Parinda). Wish they had interviewed Sivan about Iruvar instead of Terrorist, but it was also nice to see Ravi K. Chandran highlight Ratnam’s masterpiece. Would have been good to hear from PC Sriram too…

    Like

  5. Didnt follow the entire interview, but this is such a great read. Thanks Sayam / Bliss.

    Rajiv Menon is undoubtedly an ace cinematographer. and didnt know the city of Bombay in Bombay was shot in Kerala ! Wow..

    Like

  6. alex adams Says:

    The wizards of cinematography !!

    Menon is doubtless awesome
    A stray example comes to my mind not from the usual mani scenes—but the song on ash in guru –barso re
    The change in ‘hues’ and subtle changes in tone are a treat to watch.
    When ash dashes away on a cycle (!) at nite, note the change in lenses and the brilliant ‘contrast’
    just revisit this keeping in mind the multihue subtlety achieved by menon
    and ash as always is ash

    Another one who works very less but is proabably the best imo—
    Kiran Deohans–Aks (was brilliant)
    Jodha Akbar–had to make it palatable to contmporary mulpiplex audience used to gaudy tones but at the same time stay faithful to the era and appear not to be sugin artificaila light source–was awesome –difficult to understand the sheer ‘difficlulty’ he grappled with and overcame—an eg is the ash-hr song –forgottent the name but the one in the ‘bedroom’ with simulated ‘natural’ lighting
    check out the ‘reflections’ on the faces of HR and ash
    In my pen, deohans just trumps the obviosuly good binod pradhan and menon (although the latter two have a much bigger body of work)

    Like

  7. alex adams Says:

    thats one of the deohans works–apparently he took longer than the director, actors, dialogues
    The biggest deal became the ‘camera angles’
    reminds me of myself lol

    think he has done v few films but i can pick his work
    Aks, K3G, jodha akbar
    exertps of what was done in JA–Obviously has little import to the audince of these films
    but rare to find it in bollywood
    “Jodhaa Akbar, being a period film, had no electricity. Those days, they depended on mashaal (torches) and daylight. So while shooting, we were restricted by this as well. So we used light that would gel with this light.

    If there was a mashaal, then we would use a dim light from behind. It would enhance the light of the mashaal. When there was a romantic sequence, we used soft lights and colours. During war sequences, the shadows are very dark, and we tried to create an edgy feel. So we used lens and lighting depending on the scene. “

    Like

    • alex adams Says:

      In Lamhon Mein–To me,the above song by deohans signifies probably one of the best examples of ‘restrained simulated natural’ lighting in mainstream bollywood
      The various facets of moving photography he captures which illuminate without being ‘obtrusive’ remains a class act!! and the Visage stays ever so natural in this ‘lighting’
      THIS is class

      Like

  8. alex adams Says:

    Shooting “jodha Akbar’
    http://specials.rediff.com/movies/2008/feb/11sld1.htm

    Aks–the introductory few scenes-deohans and Mehra
    Slicko for their time-saw this movie on the big screen (thrice)–picture /sound quality in this link is crap but check the camera placement etc
    perhaps the first bollywood movie to be shot in Budapest!!

    Like

  9. Excellent piece ! I recent times, liked Setu’s work in “Kahaani”, the way Kolkata was shot & becomes a sort of a character.

    Liked most of the works of Santosh Sivan, Rajeev Menon, Binod Pradhan, Ashok Mehta & Ravi K Chandran.

    Like

  10. alex adams Says:

    Bella Tarrs “turin horse’
    bak to some work–but b4 that
    have talked about this film earlier
    but attended an ‘auteur workshop’ on this with hardcore ‘auteurs’ taking notes
    This film enters your system
    But not for most

    Like

  11. alex adams Says:

    haha my brain is still getting ready to be in a position to savour this first–have viewed it thrice in exclusive parts!
    Requires a certain ‘taste’ which i believe, is never congenital.
    One has to ‘groom’ oneself for his films wherein a few viewings have to be even ‘forced’
    But when it strikes, u know it !!!
    Not long ago–i mocked these films
    but not anymore–u live to learn !

    Like

  12. Ravi K. Chandran to direct his first film with Jiiva:

    [post created]

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.